Manchester United 1-0 Everton: United dominate but leave it late

The starting line-ups
Another poacher’s goal from Javier Hernandez, and another late victory for Manchester United.
Sir Alex Ferguson made many changes to his side, bringing in Darron Gibson and Johnny Evans for rare starts. Wayne Rooney played off Javier Hernandez.
David Moyes was without Johnny Heitinga, so brought Jack Rodwell into the central midfield zone alongside Phil Neville, with Tony Hibbert at right-back. Tim Cahill was on the bench.
The game went through three distinct stages: (a) in the first half, United were all over Everton and should have scored a few goals (b) for the first twenty minutes of the second, the game was much more even and (c) Ferguson’s substitutions helped United stamp their authority on the match once again in the final stages.
United dominance
In the first half, the ball spent barely any time in Manchester United’s half of the pitch. The tactical battle was almost entirely about United’s front four against Everton’s defence and two holding midfielders – and though United frequently found space and created promising situations, their final ball into the box was often wasteful.
Everton have generally got things right away from home against the top sides this season – when Gareth Bale mania was in full force, Moyes produced a clever plan to nullify Tottenham at White Hart Lane, he set up very well at the Emirates to deny Arsenal the dominance they’re used to at home – before Everton faded late on, his tactics away at Manchester City produced a great defensive display and a 2-1 win, and he also beat Chelsea in the FA Cup at Stamford Bridge.

United tried to play down their right, exploiting the space behind Leighton Baines
Here, however, they had problems in the first half, and Their main problems stemmed from the pace of Hernandez. Everton are usually good at keeping it tight between the lines, but the Mexican’s sheer pace forced Phil Jagielka and Sylvain Distin deeper. (They would also have been well aware that they were opened up by United earlier in the season at Goodison Park by Dimitar Berbatov running onto a through ball and finishing well, so they quickly dropped deep.)
Of course, this opened up space for Rooney, who played ‘in the hole’, in the role he’s mastered in recent weeks, particularly in the games against Chelsea. Phil Neville was Everton’s deepest midfielder, to the right, and Jack Rodwell moved higher up the pitch towards the left, so Rooney found space by moving into the inside-right channel, between the lines. Rodwell was slow to close Rooney down.
In fact, most of Everton’s problems occurred in that zone of the pitch. Leighton Baines is one of Everton’s best attacking threats, but as we’ve noted throughout the season, Everton are also vulnerable down that side of the pitch defensively. As Baines tried to move forward into the attack, both Rooney and Hernandez moved in behind, and United were keen to hit balls into that space – see the opportunity for Nani that came after Antonio Valencia outmuscled Baines.
Nani was disappointing – Tony Hibbert looked vulnerable early on but eventually got into the game and defended well. Nani can play on either side, but he remains much better on the right – when used on the left, he’s too keen to come inside and use his right foot, making him much more predictable. His delivery here was poor.
Second half
Moyes got little from Jermaine Beckford or Diniyar Bilyaletdinov, so brought on Victor Anichebe with Tim Cahill just off him. Anichebe moved to the left and helped pin back Fabio, whilst Leon Osman on that side also did a good defensive job. With John O’Shea hardly a great attacking outlet on the other side, United were much less dangerous with less drive from full-back.
Rodwell also picked up his game and was much more aware of Rooney’s movement in behind him. He couldn’t afford to drop goalside of Rooney and completely concede the midfield battle to United, so instead worked on preventing balls from the midfielders and full-backs being played into Rooney. United suddenly looked a little nervous, and Everton held the ball better.
United rally late on
A couple of factors combined to get United back in the game. Fitness was key – on a very hot day, United had 61% of possession, and Everton had to work very hard without the ball. Equally important, though, was United’s ability to change the game from the bench.
Michael Owen and Ryan Giggs came on for Nani and Gibson in the most eye-catching moves, but equally important was Patrice Evra’s introduction for O’Shea. With first Nani and then Rooney playing on the left and always looking to bring the ball inside, Evra stretched the play, made United more dynamic when spreading play to the flanks (Anderson should be praised for consistently good, positive diagonal balls) and from 70 minutes onwards they were all over Everton again.
Despite all the changes, it was Valencia down the right, the main battleground early on in the game, that produced the goal. He put pressure on Distin to win the ball, dragged the Frenchman out to the flank, and then his deflected cross found Hernandez at the far post for what we can start to call a ‘classic’ Hernandez goal.
Conclusion
A few changes established United’s position in the ascendency, but equally their persistence and commitment to their usual tactics – get the ball out wide, and get men into the box – proved crucial at the end of the game. The good movement from Hernandez, Owen and Rooney inside the penalty area was particularly notable.
Moyes’ switches midway through the game allowed Everton to compete – but making two changes so early meant he couldn’t react to United’s three attack-minded substitutions in the second half.
Manchester United 1-0 Everton: United dominate but leave it late




Great work as always ZM.
And here I was working on a blog writing how “smaller” sides have changed their tactics and were not afraid to have a go against the big clubs this season. So much for that today. Everton played like a Sunderland, Stoke, Fulham or Reading played a few seasons back at Old Trafford. Praying to nick a goal somewhere, most likely off a set piece, but pretty much would be very happy with a 0-0. Hell, even a 1-0 or a 2-0 loss seemed acceptable to them, as long as they wouldn’t get embarrassed.
They played too deep, and were content to defend, relying on their CBs defensive midfielders, clogging up the middle and Howard. The whole of the midfield was behind the ball, leaving the very poor Beckford isolated.
United on the other hand looked very comfortable, too lax even, without the cutting edge and urgency in front of goal. Poor decision making and poor crosses resulted in a scoreless first half without United having many chances on goal. The Everton defence will get the plaudits for defending bravely, and they were quite good, but Moyes’ tactics were very negative.
At halftime Moyes did make positive changes bringing on Cahill to support their new striker Anichebe. But United attacked and attacked. Wave after wave they came. Till that late goal.
In the end Everton deserved absolutely nothing because of their negative tactics. Fergie rotated once again and United could have been pressured, but none really came. Everton’s best chance came from a long range Rodwell deflected shot which forced a brilliant save from van der Saar. But for all their defensive tactics United were able to isolate the Toffies’ fullbacks many times with Everton worrying more about the middle of the pitch and daring United to make crosses that could be, and were, defended by the very good Jagielka and Distin. It mostly worked with Everton dealing with most of what United threw at them.
Have to mention Anderson here, he was brilliant. Showing off the vision and passing range every South American expert was accusing him off but which were rarely seen for United. Of course today he was able to attack and pass at will due to Everton playing so deep. But if he can play with the freedom he had today more regularly (with either Carrick or Fletcher behind him) then perhaps United are not as desperate for a creative midfielder as everyone (including me) thinks. Of course this is a big if. Anderson has had a few injuries and aside from him being played mostly as a destroyer, he has not been anywhere close to consistent. In fact his first season for United was his best. But this season he has shown glimpses of the players that United paid so much money for.
And Hernandez, thankfully there was value in the market last winter and spring. What a revelation he is. His game needs improvement in several areas, holding up the ball, passing, decision making, learning to stay onside with his great pace (starting to resemble Pipo); he also is a pretty poor dribbler. But for all those shortcomings, what a nose for goal. He has the instincts of an in prime Ruud, not of some kid who has switched leagues and has only played well the season before. One step closer to 19 for us. Need 7 more points from 4 games. And two CL games away from this being a great season. Not bad for a team no one gave a chance to, and not bad for a team that has not played “the United way” for most of the season.
Teams have come to Old Trafford this season thinking they can get something from their games. They haven’t been parking the proverbial bus and see the result. Only 2 points dropped from United.
I can understand why Moyes did set his team up defensively. Tim Howard though, he was acting as if USA were leading in a world cup final with 10 minutes left to play. Shocking time wasting.
It’s been a while since I’ve seen a proper United review on this site. I’d also like to add that United seem to rely too much on counter attacking some times when possession should be maintained. I still feel ball control/ball retention under pressure is lacking in some of the players although Rooney has improved in this aspect.
Well yes, United have been very good at home. But Everton have been the on form team in the league. And once they give up a goal there is almost no way back, they were set up to defend, Howard wasted time all match, and then they are expected to turn it around completely and attack. It almost never works. Especially is a team is as defensive as Everton were.
United sometimes, like earlier today, have trouble breaking teams down, so when Rooney, Hernandez, Valencia and Nani are on the pitch, its advisable to make use of their speed and counter attack before the opposition set up and clog up the passing lanes like Everton did. Anderson was brilliant today, but all too often United let opposing keepers have rather easy days. In seasons past the opposition keeper was usually their best player, even if the score was 4-0. This season we have seen United hardly trouble keepers with accurate shots.
There is a tendency for deliberate, slow passing and lack of movement to create chances. United become static and have getting quality shots on goal. So this season ball retention did not always mean scoring chances.
I have no clue on Anderson, really. As he costs somewhere around 20 million pound, people are surely expecting more from him.
I wish to see Paul Scholes in him, but he does not score goals or unleash long-range shots very often. His long-range passes are not too brilliant either.
I wish to see Luka Modric, but he does not read the game, dribble, and hold-up play as good as the Tottenham talisman.
I wish to see Javier Mascherano, but he does not tackle opponents and do excellent job defensively.
What kind of player he is developing? For a 20 million pound guy (he was even more expensive than Nani!), I absolutely have no clue. But IMO Ferguson must have an idea. Look at what Fletcher and Nani have become after people said that those guys are Ferguson’s mistakes and fringe players….
But it’s interesting to see if someone like Wesley Sneijder comes to United. I can guarantee that Fergie will bring a fresh force in midfield next season, and surely Anderson will have tough times competing with him with his current abilities.
Every South American expert I heard or read claims that Fergie is using Anderson wrong. He was supposed to be the next Ronaldinho, an attacking midfielder with hardly a defensive worry. Meanwhile from the start of his United career he was used as a destroyer who rarely ventured forward. This season he is being given a freer role, with license to attack, so perhaps we will see him at his best. He’s shown glimpses so far. maybe an injury free season and with Fletcher, and Carrick on form behind him, he can be the player we all hope he would become.`
the setup at man utd doesnt allow a free role for anderson he cant play on the wing as he doesnt dribble much and so the only possible position is in the middle with defensive responsibilities and i dont think he is creative enough to give him the play maker role in 4-2-3-1
Agree. Do you guys know why Ferguson never bought the likes of Mesut Oezil, Kaka, Deco, Riquelme, Rafael van der Vaart? Because the way they play doesn’t suit his system; that’s why.
In the history of his career Ferguson never used a trequartista like Kaka or Ronaldinho, NEVER. Once he bought Veron and deployed him as a defensive-minded playmaker. If Ferguson bought Wesley Sneijder, he is more likely to be put in the same position as Ando now. So Ando would not become an attacking midfielder. A central midfield yes, but definitely not an attacking midfielder or trequartista.
And who are these Brazillian coaches and South American experts trying to have a go against the most successful manager in British history? Ferguson meets Ando and spends time with him everyday during training; so I bet he knows Ando’s capabilities best than anyone else for now.
well with only beckford fit enough to start…
there weren’t many options Moyes could think of..
LOL. My don, couldn’t be arsed to spell Billy-Elliot-Dean-Off, so he just wrote Bily…
United fan but Philip Neville was MOTM. Destoryed a lot of moves. Also, Everton played very narrow forcing us outwide and their big defenders dealt with crosses easily. The difference was one bit of movement tbf.
It’s just too long to fit in the system. It’s the same for Schweinsteiger
Hernandez is such a talentless tap-in merchant…bar the ‘classic’ header from two yards, he was wasteful in possession, and broke down several counter attacks with sloppy passing. Appart from headless running and standing around in the box waiting for a tap-in he offers very very little.
Surely this is a wind up?
if it was that easy we would all be doing it instead of working in normal 9 to 5 jobs!!!
Not me, I hate working Saturdays.
Headless running? His movement is outstanding…
hahahaha
Are you for real?
‘he was wasteful in possession’ – Linking up the play and playing Rooney style passes is not his job, and I wouldn’t say he was wasteful in posession anyway, most of the time he did have to pass, he layed it off simply and effectively. He might have given it away a few times, like every player does.
‘Appart from headless running’ – ‘Appart’ has only one P by the way. But by his ‘headless running’ you mean to say intelligent and non stop movement which is very hard for defenders to deal against.
’standing around in the box waiting for a tap-in he offers very very little’ – ‘waiting around for tap in’s’ has got him nearly 20 goals in his first season in the toughest league in the world. It’s as if you’re criticising him for actually scoring goals!
He offers much to the all round play, he is contstantly on the move, which means he has provided options for the wingers and the midfield to play balls for him. You say he offers little to the all round play, but contributing to the all round play is what Rooney does, so Hernandez doesn’t have to. Do you want Hernandez to do what Rooney does? Where would the goals come from then, if most of the time the strikers spend is outside of the box? So maybe Hernandez doesn’t offer much to the all round team contribution, the fact is, he doesn’t have to, that’s not playing to his strengths, and the all round team contribution might suffer if it wasn’t for Hernandez’s intelligent movements and running.
hernandez overall contribution is fantastic if you forget his tally of a goal every 104 minutes average in the premier league…his work rate out of possession in terms of pressure to win the ball back is top as well as his movement while man utd are in possession constantly running in behind and creating angles
Hmmm talentless tap-in merchant. Pretty creative even from a dimwit like you. I have a feeling Fergie wouldn’t start a talentless player in his side. You should really ask Jagielka and Distin how talentless he is, but they’re probably still out of breath from trying to track him down all game. You usually don’t see hops like that on a guy that’s 5′9 either, I’d consider that talent.
“I have a feeling Fergie wouldn’t start a talentless player in his side.”
Are you kidding me? Are you using the “He knows better than you, so he’s right”-argument? Christ, you could have used any other argument like his excellent movement, his goal/min ratio, his work rate, his attitude but you chose to go for the Fergie-knows-best argument?
Where is the world heading…
You sir are an idiot and a sad human being. I just thought it was hilarious how he called a premiership player talentless and played on that some, since everybody above pretty much summed it up. And if you actually read the whole comment you’d see my other points but you’re just an internet troll who gets on pages 2 days after they’re posted. Go kill yourself, record it, and put it on 4chan you troll.
Calm down lads…
you have no idea how many options he presents to the midfield players with his intelligent movement… its a dream for midfielders like scholes xavi etc to have players like Javier hernandez in front of them presenting so many options
His other talent is his amazing shooting accuracy and conversion %. go look at the stats for that
Javier Hernandez has scored five headed goals from just eight headers on target in the Premier League.
Javier Hernandez has fired in 47% of his attempts on target in the Premier League.
5 – Javier Hernandez has scored more goals than any other Premier League player as a substitute this season.
Javier Hernández has scored 15 goals from just 22 shots on target in the Premier League & Champions League.
Javier Hernandez has scored 11 goals from just 15 shots on target in the Premier League this season.
Opta
Yeah, are you commenting on Chicarito or Fernando Torres bro? Three shots on goal, three on target, and one of them became match-winning goal –I think Hernandez was brilliant in the game.
My god. What an idiot
haha what an idiot…must be a livepool fan i guess
I was gonna make a comment about Man Utd attacking and Everton defending, but after reading all of the above about Hernandez I just can’t stop laughing…..Hernandez does need to improve on aspects of his game, but he will over the next couple of years and will then truly become World-Class (if he isn’t already)….
…..all you guys crack me up….!!!!!
if he’s world class? you’d have to put up a good argument to say he isnt the best striker in the world
He doesn’t score 50 goals in a season, assist half as many and single-handedly destroys teams like a certain Messi does.
Hernandez is there to finish the attacks, which he does brilliantly, but to call him “best striker in the world” when all he does is tap-ins is SERIOUS overkill.
Considering all aspects of the game, Hernandez is not world class. However, he fits the role he has at United like a glove, and is pretty much irreplacable. Much like van Persie at Arsenal or Messi at Barca, there simply is none like him.
Everton defended quite well without the ball (apart from getting a grip on the slippery Rooney), but with the ball I think they got it all wrong. They had been playing so direct in the first half, getting the ball out to the wingers or looking too early for the isolated Beckford… and constantly surrendered possession as a result.
The arrival of Cahill improved things a bit. Partly because he replaced the poor Bilyaletdinov, but also because he wanted to receive the ball to feet in midfield.
I felt they would have been much better off if the central midfield trio had kept the ball with short passes around Anderson/Gibson from the first minute onwards. That’s what Cahill seemed to be attempting but, of course, it takes more than one man.
It’s a much easier thing to type than to do, but with the shape of the two sides I think Everton’s best plan today might have been to defend with the ball. Perhaps they simply lacked the personnel, I guess. Rodwell is a talent but inexperienced positionally and not assertive enough, and Neville is certainly no regista. I wonder what a healthy Arteta might have done.
As it was, it always felt like there was only going to be one result the longer the game went on.
Not just Arteta, Fellaini’s presence was sorely missed in the midfield.
Ferdinand on Anichebe… Dead on penalty…. How could de ref miss that ??
The ball was out of Anichebe’s control so it wasn’t a goal scoring opportunity. And the foul wasn’t exactly blatant, looked like a coming together rather than a pre-meditated trip.
Top analysis as always ZM.
No complaints in the result from a Blue perspective – we defended well and had a good shape but the ball just wouldn’t stick up front especially 1st half. Beckford has shown he is premier league standard inside the opposition box but outside it he is barely championship standard. We looked better 2nd period with more physicality to hold the ball up but it was still one way traffic for the most part. Good shout on Anderson also – thought he had a real incision to his passing in the final third today.
Cheers.
Everton draw clever plan which keep defend in first half and attack in 2nd half.
Some people think Everton must give a go from 1st half but if lesser team play open game with better team then result is almost certain.
It is probability game; You must limit better team’s chances at minimum and try few attacking moves and see it work or not. It is proven way to beat better team.
Everton defend very well; Only last moment header from Hernandez save Utd from possible calamity.
Hernandez can punish ruthlessly if team form high line defense; The off-ball movement and finding space combined with sheer pace and accuracy of shooting make him very good center forward.
…maybe ZM would consider a end of season write up on the differences between Hernandez leading the line this year and Rooney last year..???
“In the history of his career Ferguson never used a trequartista like Kaka or Ronaldinho, NEVER.” The reasons advanced for Sir Odious not buying a trequartista: shouldn’t they also have precluded his buying Bulgarov? And yet he did.
While I wish David Moyes would make more of an effort to win matches like this one, it’s hard to fault him given what he had to work with. The lineup picked itself based on who was actually fit to play (the only possible decisions once it was decided Cahill couldn’t start were Bilyaletdinov over Gueye and Beckford over Anichebe), and it wasn’t exactly one that lent itself to any sort of attack — Baines and Osman were the only starters with the remotest bit of attacking creativity in blue.
Of course, given how Moyes has approached this fixture in the past, I’m not sure that his approach would have been much different were Saha, Arteta, Cahill, and Fellaini all out there.
If you havent seen the game and are still wondering how in the world it ended 6-3, than check out the tactical breakdown @ http://bigmatchbreakdown.wordpress.com/2011/04/24/real-madrid-vs-valencia-higuain-and-kaka-combine-to-devastating-effect/
Cant wait for the Manu – RM Champion’s League Final!!
No disrespect meant for Barca & Shalke, but that would be a classic final between two great sides & great managers.
ЎHola!
su idea es muy buena
[url=http://rsfiles.serveblog.net/]Garretot[/url]
Osman is a very promising talent, but do you think a bigger club will bother luring him away? I could see him doing well at Liverpool and Arsenal.
Can we really class a 29-year-old as a “promising talent”?