Valencia 5-0 Villarreal: spare man at the back, and direct football going forward

The starting line-ups
Third-placed Valencia demolished fourth-placed Villarreal at the Mestalla.
Unai Emery brought Ever Banega back into the side in the centre of midfield, and also recalled Portuguese defenders Miguel and Ricardo Costa at the back.
Juan Carlos Garrido was forced to change things at the back, after the news that centre-back Gonzalo Rodriguez is out for the rest of the season with a broken leg. He gave a rare start to Kiko, resisting the temptation to move Carlos Marchena from his ‘new’ central midfield position.
Valencia started the game in control, and aside from a brief spell towards the end of the first half, that was how the game stayed. Villarreal’s sheer inexperience at the back cost them, whilst Emery got the better of Garrido tactically.
Spare man
Pre-match television graphics showed Valencia lining up in their usual 4-2-3-1 system, but this was not to be the case. Instead, as in the reverse fixture earlier this season, Emery decided to use a three-man defence, with central midfielder Mehmet Topal deployed as an additional centre-back.
The idea here was basically to give Valencia a spare man at the back. The problem with facing Giuseppe Rossi and and Nilmar is that they make unusual runs, from inside to outside – if they’re tracked too far, it leaves the centre of the pitch completely open. Therefore, a spare man there is a good idea, and has the extra benefit of being able to cover when the Villarreal strikers use their pace to get onto balls over the top.
Pressing
The start of the game was played at a high tempo, with the pace largely set by the home side. Valencia pressed Villarreal excellently, and whilst Garrido’s men continued with their short, patient passing, they weren’t quite on their game, and struggled to get Santi Cazorla, the link player, involved.
Villarreal also pressed high up, and the result of both sides taking a proactive approach to defend was a congested midfield battle, with the play squeezed into the middle third of the pitch. Both sides were caught offside in the opening moments.
High line exploited
Like in Arsenal’s trip to Blackpool earlier in the day, the key here was an offside line being continually exploited by a striker. Here it was Roberto Soldado, fresh from four goals in his last outing against Getafe. He played towards the right of the pitch, up against the newcomer Kiko, and managed to successfully break past the Villarreal backline in the right-hand channel on three separate occasions in the first half. Twice he was denied by Diego Lopez, but the other time he took the shot very early, and finished into the far corner.

Valencia's transitions from defence to attack were simple but effective. With Villarreal's wide players coming inside, Valencia's wing-backs could charge forward to create 3 v 2 situations down the flanks - Miguel did this for Soldado's first goal
Villarreal were putting a decent amount of pressure on the ball in midfield, but they struggled to cope with Valencia defenders coming out with the ball from the back. In particular, since Villarreal’s wide players end up in the centre of the pitch, it was fairly easy for Valencia’s wing-backs to move forward in possession, and they had time to pick a pass after creating 3 v 2 situations – see the diagram on the right. Miguel provided the pass for Soldado’s opener.
Valencia continued to exploit Villarreal’s weaknesses intelligently. Emery’s side is often praised for their short, patient passing approach – but here they attacked extremely quickly, often taking advantage of Cazorla out of position down Villarreal’s left – in fact, the first three goals all came down that side.
Valencia remain in control
Emery suffered the loss of Tino Costa towards the end of the first half, and brought on Angel Dealbert instead – he played at centre-back, and Topal moved back into midfield, strengthening Valencia defensively in that part of the pitch.
Villarreal were surprisingly clueless with the ball. The woes started from the back, where their makeshift back four simply isn’t as comfortable in possession as Garrido would like, but continued deep in midfielder (where Bruno and Marchena were pressed), and simply getting the ball forward was a problem. Rossi was barely noticeable, and Nilmar scooped Villarreal’s only decent chance over the crossbar just before half time.
Latter stages
At 2-0, Garrido tried to change things by removing Juan Capdevila and throwing on Marco Ruben, a more physical central striker which in theory allowed them to play longer passes (also, this substitution had got Villarreal back i nthe game in the reverse fixture) but the only effect of this was to further weaken Villarreal down their left – and they conceded the third goal almost immediately as Bruno failed to cover that side of the pitch.
From then on, Villarreal’s heads dropped and Valencia took full advantage – Juan Mata and Pablo Hernandez were in superb form and ruthlessly demolished Villarreal’s backline. More impressively, the home side kept up their intensity, their tempo and their pressure on the ball, and weren’t troubled at the back despite Villarreal’s extra striker.
Conclusion
Two factors here, at each end of the pitch. First, Emery swapped his back four for a back three (or a back five, if you like) which allowed a spare man and therefore guarded against the movement and pace of Villarreal’s forwards. Going forward, Valencia had an obvious strategy to play direct football, moving the ball quickly down the flanks and getting Soldado in behind Kiko – it worked excellently, and though Villarreal themselves had a spare man, the back four simply wasn’t quick enough to justify playing so high up the pitch.
Almost every individual played well for Valencia – the movement and interplay of the front three was fantastic, whilst Banega pulled the strings in midfield, and overshadowed Villarreal’s technical players in the centre.
Valencia now have a commanding hold of third place in La Liga – six points, plus a head-t0-head advantage – which surely means the end of the fight for that position. Villarreal, meanwhile, have an eight-point advantage over fifth-placed Sevilla, and may now turn their attention to the Europa League.
Valencia 5-0 Villarreal: spare man at the back, and direct football going forward




Free proof-reading: you mean, fifth-placed Sevilla
.
I do indeed, thanks!
Hmmm… Why should Villareal think abt the Europa league..? I think they will play in the Champions league qualifiers right ?
He means concentrating on their current run in the Europa League.
Yup… My bad… Sry…
Any answers as to why does Borja Valero play right midfielder nowadays? He is so much more of a natural central midfielder, and when fielded on the right, he often drifts into his ‘normal’ position, leaving the flanks free. Obviously, this is not so much of a problem when attacking, but he does this even out of possession, leaving his right-back Mario (himself not a regular starter) unprotected. It would have been a better solution if Marchena played instead of Kiko, Valero alongside Bruno Soriano and perhaps Cani of the right, jst like they did earlier in the season.
Or as Cani is injured, they could have played Cicinho instead. Surely it’s more important to be sure and safe in the middle and at the back rather than on the flanks…
Villareal’s tactics and formation, this season, require wingers to drift inside. I would assume this as a first and the most important reason why he plays more centrally, not his previous experience or position.
Borja Valero (one of La Liga’s best performers outside the big two) has a free role along with Cazorla, they only really cover the wings in a 4-4-2 when defending in 2 banks of 4. more often than not, the attacking midfielders of Villarreal can exchange positions with the forwards, creating a fluid 4-2-2-2, as Nilmar & Rossi are more second strikers rather than clear 9’s
Villarreal have played, since Pellegrini arrived to the club, this way, that means, without real wingers. They concentrate in playing throught the middle and that’s why Borja Valero and Santi Cazorla drift inside of the pitch.
Sorry for writing ambiguously; so I know that those two are supposed to drift inside when in possession, but Borja often does that when defending, coming back to his natural position in the middle, leaving that right midfield zone free for any opposing left-backs/left wingers. And surely, that is going to be exploited when teams will have enough video about it. Ball to the right centre midfielder – Borja coming to the middle of the park – long diagonial pass to the left – The opponent is behind Villarreal’s midfield and driving at 2 vs 1 on Mario and his 15 career appearences in Primera División…
HzgPxf AFAICT you’ve covreed all the bases with this answer!
One of the best articles of the year: 5 comments.
herp derp let’s all go talk about Chelsea v ManU
“herp derp let’s all go talk about Chelsea v ManU”
Don’t forget to talk about the referees too!
At least there are comments here; the Udinese-Roma game has none at all…
it has one now…hee hee…!!!!!!!
Good point. I hadn’t tohuhgt about it quite that way.
Great analysis. Thank you.
the 5-man defence (or however it is called) has caused us a lot of problems this year.
1. I was at Madrigal for the first round league game. We never got into the game in the 1st half and gave up the lead. We played better in the 2nd half, no change in tactics but just better execution and less errors with the short passes. FT 1-1
2. 1st leg of Copa in Mestalla, we suffered all day, could’ve been 2-0 or 3-0 but Valencian strikers’ profligacy and our brilliant keeper Diego Lopez ensured it ended 0-0
3. 2nd leg 1st half at Madrigal, Same old story and this time we fell behind 0-2. same system, same weaknesses exploited. But second half saw the introduction of Marco Ruben and almost immediately he scored, Unai moved his lines back to defend and in no time it ws 3-2 and ended 4-2.
Last night, there was one other key factor involved. Fatigue. Valencia played last sunday (6days rest) vs Villarreal played on thursday (2days rest). Going into the game the only way we could hold up 90 minutes was to stay ahead in the game and not having to chase. After the 2nd goal of Mata, the legs got heavy and everything went downhill.
More than being outthought tactically, if we can execute our system better, we will achieve good results. Cos clearly we beat the same system with largely the same tactics in the Copa 2nd leg. Villarreal has scored only 9/30 points in the last 10 games. We need to have a deeper squad. about 10/11 out of the 25 were playing for B. At one point last night all our back 4(bruno,kiko,musacchio,mario) played for B last year
. I hope people dont deem these as excuses, I would hate to use excuses to justify a very bad game.
The reason Borja is playing on the wing rather than at the center is because it has worked for us. We sacrificed a creative player in Cani for a solid double-pivot of Marchena-Bruno. (this underlines the fact, how good Senna was). This worked for us brilliantly against Leverkusen,(Senna played in the 1st leg of Napoli),@Athletic and Twente.
We definitely missed Cani off the bench last night. Also the impressive Catala wasnt fully fit either. Which meant Kiko got the start.
As for Cicinho, he is not a good fit for this team. We tried him in Jan, didnt work. Garrido doesnt trust him anymore.
Villarreal need to concentrate on Thursday without much damage (in terms of injuries). Porto will be a big big test. And I fully expect Porto to play a system similar to what Valencia has employed against us. It is upto us to execute and get an early goal and then things will start falling in place.
I hope we get to the final. I want to go to Dublin
never been there.
Cheers – @aupasubmarino
any news on Matilla? seems to have mastered Xavi’s pelopina, but I doubt he can perform at the moment without an experienced defensive midfielder (basically Marcos Senna)
Matilla is in Garrido’s doghouse for some indiscipline earlier in the season. He is very good but we have seen very very little of him this season. I dont have enough data to make any statement on his current level.
That’s basically it in a nutshell. Villarreal played as poorly as I’ve seen them do all season, and certainly fatigue has an effect when two roughly evenly-matched teams square up. Their defenders got lost on some pretty basic one-two passing plays throughout the match and the whole midfield unit looked gassed early in the 2nd half.
That being said, Valencia were also firing on all cylinders tonight, bringing back memories from their golden team 10 years ago with those one-touch/two-touch buildups. The tempo wasn’t as hectic but the style was soothingly familiar.
Every time I watch Valencia, I’m more impressed with Jeremy Mathieu. He seemed like one of those bargain deals for a rotation player two years ago as Emery’s first signing but the dude is the real deal on the left flank. Strong, positionally smart and a reliable crosser. Shame about Evra bossing that position in the national team, I’d like to see what Mathieu or Tremoulinas could do on international level.
Yes, Valencia has a very good team. If not for Emery’s strange tinkering ways the should have been doing better.
And I still cant believe how they lost to Schalke after taking the lead in both games.
Well, it was the same story as the 0-1 defeat to Sevilla the other week. Valencia created the better chances but didn’t take advantage of them, or were denied by excellent goalkeeping.
As for Emery’s tinkering, it should be remembered that 4 established players left Valencia in the summer (Villa, Silva, Marchena, and Baraja), while another half-dozen arrived. Emery has tried various combinations to find what works best. In contrast, last season the line-ups and formations were more limited because the players had been playing together for some time when he was hired to manage Valencia.
Perhaps this miserable showing was the result of fatigue AND poor planning? Miguel has been erratic this season and had been left out of the squad a few weeks ago; what was needed was a speedy player to run at him and make him suffer (much like Royston Drenthe did when Valencia visited Hercules in the first half of the season). Could Montero have done it, if he hadn’t been loaned out? Rossi could have, if he hadn’t played so intensely in the middle of the week.
And defending more deeply in the second half only resulted in the players getting confused, and then overrun. Both Pablo and Mata were allowed to run right at and past defenders, with no attempts made to stop them or slow them down, it seemed.
Good luck in the Europa Cup!
Thanks, we need all the luck. last nights game was one of those groundhog days..I hope we flushed all the malaise in that 5-0 drubbing.
1. thank you for this post, aupasubmarino. It’s super-informative.
2. very sad to see the submarine so squeezed by injuries and a small squad.
3. A matchup of two teams with managers with interesting tactical ideas. Villarreal seem to be more likely to stick with their strategy regardless of opponents. Valencia, by contrast, seem to be willing to adapt from 3 to 4 at the back depending on circumstances sort of like Chile under Bielsa.
Brilliant, this aupasubmarino post is exactly why ZM kicks ass
thanks for the kind words. this is my first time on this site. as my nickname suggests, you will find hard to find a bigger submarino fan
The first goal was the result of poor pressing rather than a 3v2 situation. As has been has been pointed out elsewhere, when playing the offside trap so high up the pitch you should pressurize the man with the ball at all times. That is the point of keeping the play in a congested, narrow band. Miguel, who is not known for his incisive passing, was allowed time and space to play a simple through pass into the path of Soldado, whose run and shot were timed to perfection. An even more glaring failure was Tino Costa’s pass that sliced straight through the middle a few minutes later, which Soldado blasted right at López .
Perhaps Garrido deserves credit for sticking to his footballing principles and taking the game to Valencia, much like Villareal did at the Bernabeu and the Camp Nou, but by the middle of the second half his players were clearly out of gas and being overrun on the left, on the right, and in the center.
I think villarreal is earnestly trying to establish a system like Barça where team at every level plays the same way. It took a long time and a lot of money for Barça so I am not sure how long it will take for a small town club like us and how long before the Roig’s get impatient. But we will enjoy it as long as it lasts. Everytime i see Villarreal struggle against a side like Valencia i wonder if they should have a plan B but as even Barça realized last season a viable plan is difficult to cultivate when your whole philosophy is so ingrained and deep-rooted. My guess is we will continue the same way, what is missing is a to begin with a deeper squad at the start of the season and keep executing
Hey aupasubmarino
I find that, for a small town club like Villareal, its absolutely outstanding the way they manage to get into champions league almost each year, and how good they do in europe (sooner or later they will win something, lets hope this year!). The philosophy they are trying to raise similar to Barcelona, is very brave and it will achieve great results if it has continuity (its working great already, with so little money compared to big clubs!)
Salutations from a cule, I will be cheering for Villareal in europa league!
Gonzalo Rodríguez’s absence was also key for Villarreal, and Garrido is going to have to do something in order to solve this matter, since Kiko started again a match more than a year later and it was as disastrous as the previous time – he played at Mestalla last season and Villarreal lost 4-1 with him being sent off after only 27 minutes. He never coped with playing with Musacchio, who was at fault in the first goal as he broke the offside.
Another point worth mentioning is that Emery switched wings in the second half and both players, Pablo Hernández and Mata, were more active and slammed Villarreal with two assists and two goals. This change made sense because their nature of their game for this match was to drift inside as Mathieu and Miguel had the flanks for themselves, and Emery realized things could get better despite a very good first half display.
so is the RFEF really considering Unai Emery to replace Del Bosque when the latter decides to leave?
This result i think would help both of them. Valencia gets 3rd spot and can focus coming Real Madrid match at home as trophy match.
Villareal get 4th and can concentrate on Europa.
we need to be careful, we have Sevilla away in 2 weeks. This weeks home game against relegation strugglers Zaragoza is a must win.
shame you didn’t review villareal v twente – don’t think i’ve ever seen a gameplan (twente’s choice to play 3-5-2) go so obviously and horribly wrong! should be shown to tactics deniers …
If you have to do it, you might as well do it right