Milan v Tottenham: tactical preview

Tottenham's possible starting XI. If Modric is ruled out, Sandro will probably start instead
In theory, Tottenham have the perfect footballing style to cause Milan problems.
Max Allegri’s side have been vulnerable to the same two things this season. First, pace on the counter-attack. Milan are an old side, and often can’t compete with raw speed from younger legs. Second, width. Whether playing a 4-3-3 or a 4-3-1-2, Milan’s front three leave the defending to the seven players behind them. The full-backs often become exposed to tricky wingers, and allow too many crosses into the box. Cesena showed the way to beat Milan earlier this season – sit back, and break down the flanks.
Spurs selection
Few other clubs in Europe play two traditional wingers like Spurs – Aaron Lennon on the right, Gareth Bale on the left. Unfortunately, Bale has been ruled out of this one, meaning Lennon – likely to be up against Luca Antonini – has a big responsibility to provide drive and direct running from the flank.
On the other side, Bale will be a big loss considering Milan’s aforementioned problems, and taking into account his impact the last time he played at the San Siro. His replacement will be Niko Kranjcar – a completely different player, who likes to come inside and link up with others, rather than getting down the line and putting balls into the box. In a way, that might help Spurs – their ball retention away from home is often poor (granted, partly down to an admirable willingness to attack full pelt for 90 minutes), but in a two-legged tie like this, Spurs might want to keep it tight away from home in the first leg, which means possession play would work well.
On that note, the possible injury loss of Luka Modric is another big blow, meaning Spurs will be without the two stars of the victory over Inter in the group stage. The further absence of Rafael van der Vaart would be a disaster. Tom Huddlestone and Jermaine Jenas are also unavailable, meaning Harry Redknapp really is down to the bares bones here. It is likely that van der Vaart’s availability will influence whether Spurs play 4-4-2 or 4-4-1-1 – a very small difference in terms of the positioning of the relevant players (as Jermain Defoe drops off when Spurs don’t have the ball) but a larger influence upon what Spurs do with the ball in the final third.
Milan selection

Milan's possible starting line-up
Milan have their own injury problems in midfield. Andrea Pirlo, Kevin-Prince Boateng and Massimo Ambrosini are out, whilst new signing Mark van Bommel is cup-tied. Rino Gattuso and Mathieu Flamini look to be certain starters, whilst young German midfielder Alexander Merkel may get a start to complete the trio. Another option would be to move Thiago Silva forward into the deep-lying midfield role he’s taken up recently, with some success, which might work especially well if van der Vaart starts – see how David Moyes used Johnny Heitinga, a converted centre-back, to stifle his fellow Dutchman earlier this season.
Upfront, with Antonio Cassano cup-tied after playing for Sampdoria in the qualifiers, Allegri has to choose three from Clarence Seedorf, Pato, Zlatan Ibrahimovic and Robinho. Ibrahimovic will play, Seedorf looks a good bet considering the defensive-minded nature of the midfield three, and the need for a ‘link’ player, so it might be a choice between Pato and Robinho for the third spot.
Key battlegrounds
With such a potent attacking trio and three central midfielders dominating the middle of the pitch, expect Milan to have the running early on in the game. Spurs best option is probably to play on the counter-attack, despite Bale’s absence. Defoe’s pace over the top could cause problems, especially if Silva plays in midfield and Mario Yepes (35) joins Alessandro Nesta (34) at the back. Meanwhile, Peter Crouch seems to be a European specialist, causing Champions League sides far more problems than Premier League side, and with Milan vulnerable to crosses this might be a promising approach.
Wilson Palacios is a key man for Spurs, as he occupies the zone Milan’s trequartista will look to play in. Palacios has been hit and miss in recent months, but is probably more suited for that job tonight than Huddlestone or Jenas. Modric’s passing would be invaluable, but the sideways balls of Palacios and Sandro might work well – spreading the play from flank to flank.
Milan will try and get their full-backs forward to provide width, meaning Lennon and Kranjcar must be disciplined (something they’re both reasonably good at). Upfront, expect the unexpected from Robinho or Pato, whilst Ibrahimovic offers more movement than one might expect. In particular, he pulls to the right, and might relish aerial battles with Benoit Assou-Ekotto.
With Milan lacking Andrea Pirlo and their midfield not overwhelmingly creative, Spurs’ midfield can afford to stand off, sit deep and focus on keeping it tight between midfield and attack, before breaking at pace – think of their goal on the break against Aston Villa over Christmas. Redknapp is notorious for being ‘not much of a tactician’, but whilst Milan start as favourites, Spurs’ natural approach tonight might be the perfect strategy.
Milan v Tottenham: tactical preview





BARCA ARSENAL PREVIEW PLEASEEEEEEH!!!!!!!!!!!
he’ll do that one when they are about to play
get off this site.
Allegri, not Ancelotti. Otherwise good read
Ancelotti’s got a tough choice then.
Picking between Drogba and Torres on Monday then between Pato, Robinho, Ibrahimovic and Seedorf a few days later.
Haha, good one mate
Milan selection, second paragraph, Ancelotti isn’t manager any more, but you know that!
Good article, looks like VDV will play (according to the twitterverse). Should be a good game.
Argh, thanks!
Excuse me if I’m confusing concepts here, but you say Spurs’ style matches up well against AC Milan, and I agree with that. However, you also say that Tottenham can afford to sit deep and break with speed.
Tottenham’s natural game is to press the opponents quite a lot in midfield, and if they did this while the defence sat back, then they’d be killed in between the lines, with Milan passing around them with their numbers advantage in the middle.
So considering that AC Milan’s forwards are really potent, and apart from Seedorf, they lack some creativity in the middle, can somebody clarify what the best approach to dealing with this would be?
I meant in terms of width, though it’s a good point you raise. However I don’t think that their natural games is always to press, especially against big sides. Against Arsenal, Chelsea and United they’ve sat back much more, then countered…
I know Robinho has been in good form recently but I would start Pato in this match. Not just because he is a fantastic player but I think Milan would do well to exploit Pato’s pace over the top against Spurs’ at times suicidally high defensive line
Definitely agree, and think Spurs can potentially win the midfield battle given Milan’s injuries. Think they will do well if they play compact in defense and only use Lennon/Crouch as the outlet. I was thinking about Pienaar instead of of Krancjar, with Krancjar deputising for Modric if he’s only on the bench. He’s not quite settled and he’s not the fastest, obviously, but he might not have to be and his tendency to look for a cross rather than cut in might mean Spurs move the ball in the right way to get at Milan.
Also, for me the Milan chalkboard isn’t working, just a heads up.
I think the chances of Harry playing 4-4-2 are pretty slim, but 4-4-1-1 forces him to choose between Crouch (effective in Europe so far) and Defoe (pace). Not sure if lumping Huddlestone in with Jenas is fair as the big man has become increasingly important over the last two years. Still waiting for news on Modric, fingers crossed. Also worried about coming up against Ibra, rather good on his day.
Incidentally, Thiago Silva has to be one of the most under-rated defenders around. I don’t think I’ve seen him put a foot wrong for Milan so far.
Totally agree…. playing along side Nesta, most will be overlooked. But I think Silva has been solid and he’s gaining valuable time playing alongside someone as good as Nesta.
That break against Villa was more than to 2 of their quickest being involved in the move along with VDV who is clever, it isnt one of those pre-plan break that JM’s Inter churned out regurlarly.
Can VanderVaart play Modric role here? Had seen him play central for Holland; this allow Harry to field both Defoe and Crouch
Would be interesting if Milan went 4-2-3-1, playing Ibra, Pato, Robinho, and Seedorf with Gattuso/Flamini playing the double pivot, allowing for more of your creative players. Or Allegri could play Silva in one of the holding positions, picking up VDV or Defoe when he drops in. When Defoe pushes up to make 2 up top, then Silva could drop in making 3 v 2 at the back.
But unless Milan have been working on this for a while in trainging, it’s highly unlikely they’ll try anything like that. Switching from system to system tends to muddle the team cohesiveness, fluency. Confusion and uncertaintly. The knockout out stages aren’t really the best place to experiment.
“playing Ibra, Pato, Robinho, and Seedorf with Gattuso/Flamini playing the double pivot”
Yes. I’ve been waiting for them to do this for a while (somewhere deep ion a comment thread here I suggested it months ago) with sort of an Arsenalish cast. If Abate’s fit, I would play him on the right (since he’ll defend) and Pato on the left (since he’ll defend more than ‘Binho), Seedorf behind Ibra linking attack and the rest of the team. S for the holders, I’d say it depends on whether Rino or Yepes has been looking better in training – pick the one more up for the game and position Silva accordingly.
You say Cassano is cup-tied; I was under the impression that the rules had changed this year to allow playing for one team in the qualifiers, and another in the actual competition?
I thought it was mentioned after Sevilla were knocked out in the qualifiers, as to whether Fabiano would be a viable buy for a CL team. Or did I dream that?
After my own analysis and the the alignment of the formations I made several observations regarding possible outcomings:
1. If Dawson is tight man-marking Ibra, Assou-Ekotto has a lot of time and free space to roam forward the left side and will make important plays in the opposite half.
2. Milan is very dependent on central attack, so Palacios doesn’t have time for a proper ball distribution and whoever will be playing the midfield center (Sandro? why not Pienaar?) will be be left with good distribution for Krancjar or Lennon. If he fails or if he gives the ball away it will be a desaster.
3. VdV has to fall back to see ball possession.
4. Tottenham should really consider to play like Liverpool against Chelsea a few days back but who I’m talking to..
5. Milan should exploit the space between Palacios and the back 4 with Seedorf and Pato/Robihno running between the lines while Ibra seeks for space between Dawson and Gallas.
6. I expect the game running over the Assou-Ekotto side of the pitch, with a lot of possession of Milan, and Tottenham failing to link the defense with the offense..
conclusion: Easy win for Milan with a lot of touches from Ibra because Redknapp don’t consider the heavy advantage for Milan in Midfield. Its basically the “treconquista” vs. Palacios if Sandro/Krancjar/VdV fail to track back. Lennon will be massively stopped by Antonini but theres a big vacancy on the other side for Assou-Ekotto to join the attack.
conclusion: Easy win for Milan with a lot of touches from Ibra because Redknapp don’t consider the heavy advantage for Milan in Midfield. Its basically the “treconquista” vs. Palacios if Sandro/Krancjar/VdV fail to track back. Lennon will be massively stopped by Antonini but theres a big vacancy on the other side for Assou-Ekotto to join the attack.
Please keep up ur analysis mate.It would help me.I would definitely bet exactly on the opposite thing you say. Lol
Should be good, hope Milan start with Pato, Ibra and Robinho at home.
Three cheers for ZM tactical previews, the best articles on the web. It’s with previews that you see who really understands football and who hides behind hindsight.
Hey, NC, nice comment…….oh, and hip hip HOORAY!!!!! (x3)
I think we are in ‘keep it tight for the first twenty’ territory here
which is pre-Zonal Marking.
Ekotto is good at breaking forward although his crossing is as wayward as most people’s in the Spurs side.
Without Bale’s pace it is a bit too much to expect Lennon to do it all by himself,
especially as Kranjcar is not that quick.
Defoe’s pace to unsettle them? Unfortunately he is playing poorly at the moment so it will be Crouch which invites us to sling the ball forward too quickly.
I can’t see Van der Vaart having much time to support him.
Hope the game is as interesting as the pre-match analysis.
Given how many good players Spurs have, I don’t really see them being down to the bare bones – I assume Pienaar is available for one, plus they could use Defoe as a deep-lying forward (granted, a position he’s kind of useless at) or Pavlyuchenko wide if need be. Also, if I remember right Corluka has sometimes played in the midfield, so he could do that with Hutton playing right back.
Thanks for the great preview. Hope it’s still tight after this game. It’d be terribly bad luck if injuries decided this tie.
“It’d be terribly bad luck if injuries decided this tie.”
Fortunately, both teams have lots of injuries, so that won’t be the deciding factor.
I think it’s a very interesting preview.
Some stuff to think about and it gives a different look on the match, which I expected to be just another dull AC Milan home game, but could very well be exciting thanks to the possibilities you predict the Spurs are going to have tonight. I hope they really are able to surprise the Italians. Would be nice since the Champions League has become such a predictable and surprise-free competition the last few years.
We’ll see!
i also see pato starting and robinho coming off the bench for pato, seedorf or merkel depending on the score
but i haven’t been following milan’s latest games so it’s more à feeling than anything else
Robinho has played much more than Pato, and often in the trequartista role. It will either be Seedorf behind Ibra and Robinho or Robinho behind Ibra and Pato. I’m hoping for the latter.
Merkel can be had by a good midfield. That will pose serious problems for Milan. Given his weakness, I bet Allegri plays Seedorf to ensure better possession. Pato could come on late and be dangerous though.
Oddo is the weak link on Milan’s defensive line. Bale would have destroyed him. If Spurs could drift a player like Defoe out to the left, he would have a lot of success dribbling around Oddo.
Good preview.
Seeing as Thiago Silva will probably start in midfield, while Yepes will be deployed along Nesta, I think that a lot of threat can come from Lennon. VdV could be tracked by Silva, while Flamini/Gattuso should help Antonini take care of young English winger. Antonini eagerly goes forward recently. However, he’s total flop in defence as we saw in the game against Juventus. Therefore, Antonini’s lack of defensive awareness combined with Lennon’s pace and Milan’s general inability to cope with pacey wingers (as ZM stated) is from my point of view biggest threat for Milan in tonight’s clash.
Moreover, Seedorf could be dropped and instead of him Allegri should put Merkel as attacking midfielder.
“Moreover, Seedorf could be dropped and instead of him Allegri should put Merkel as attacking midfielder.”
No. Miserable idea.
Just a thought.
Seedorf is wasteful and sometimes he misplaces even short passes and he’s becoming more and more slower. He shows glimpses of class, but rarely. Well, on the other hand it could be decisive in this kind of fixture.
Merkel though is full of energy. Recently he’s not been playing as well as when Allegri started including him in first team, but I think he’s worth a shot. Anyway, I don’t consider him to be a good player defensively.
Is Pienaar fully fit? I mean, Kranjcar is a central player by trade and it would make sense to me to play him there, and Pienaar on the wing.
This is true, but the only time Kranjcar’s played centrally was against FC Twente after Jenas left the game injured.
I agree with you 100%. If Modric or VDV is out move Kranjacar there and move Pienaar out wide. Then Tottenham will have 2 wingers again allowing them to attack AC Milan’s weakness. Kranjacar is a good player but he should stay inside against a team like AC MIlan. Like ZM says he drifts inward which is okay in the EPL but not against AC Milan. He’s just going to run into Flamini and Guttoso.
Also, why would Defoe start over Crouch? Nesta and Silva are between 6 ft and 6′1. Crouch’s effectiveness is lessened when playing against the 6′3 Terry or Agger or Kompany but he should be fine with two shorter defenders. Also, if Pienaar and Lennon play Tottenham is going to be reliant on scoring from crosses. If VDV and/or Modric is out then the creativeness in the middle will be gone and Tottenham will rely on headers from crosses.
Keep Defoe for a 75th minute substitution where his speed will only be a bigger advantage going up against the tired AC Milan back four. But Tottenham won’t have a lot of MF subs available. Kind of makes moving Jaime O’Hara seem like an odd decision.
How ZM is not yet assistant manager for a professional team is beyond me. Great write-up and I’m looking forward to this game.
i think lennons gonna run riot tonight tbh, dunno about a spurs win though. if bale was playing id be leaning towards a spurs victory tho
I will prefer a 4-3-3 with pato robinho and zlatan as a front three
thiago silva in midfield with seedorf, flamini and gattuso, abbate and antonini for full backs
sandro and pienaar playing
Not surprised Merkel isn’t out there. I’ve kept my eye on him in the last couple Milan matches I’ve watched, and he’s not doing much out there….while being a real liability on defense.
Fantastic stuff. Checking up on your site at halftime and you are spot on about Thiago Silva. Seemingly it really is a 3 man defense as Abate and Antonnini are playing very high. Gattuso is doing Abate’s dirty work. I just hope he can last 90. Forza Milan!
Thanks, glad you noted it!
“Spurs best option is probably to play on the counter-attack, despite Bale’s absence. Defoe’s pace over the top could cause problems, especially if Silva plays in midfield and Mario Yepes (35) joins Alessandro Nesta (34) at the back”
“With Milan lacking Andrea Pirlo and their midfield not overwhelmingly creative, Spurs’ midfield can afford to stand off, sit deep and focus on keeping it tight between midfield and attack, before breaking at pace”
Besides it was Lennon instead of Defoe beating Yepes with pace, your prediction was spot on.
Thanks, proves I don’t talk crap *all* the time!
Impressively close prediction, ZM, to how the game went in the end: *chapeau*! Although I was initially neutral to that game, I was happy in the end to see Tottenham win because of the dirty way some of the Milan players behaved, especially Gattuso and Flamini. I wonder why Gattuso did not get sent off for choking and shoving that elderly Tottenham staff member…
On the other hand I wonder why Merkel was not brought on, where he at least is a quick young runner compared to the rest of the DMs. Probably the early Goalie substitution heavily interfered with Allegris plans/options…
Paragraph1 : Cesena showed the way to beat Milan earlier this season – sit back, and break down the flanks.
Exactly that is what happened for the Spurs goal. When Milan is putting pressure, Spurs break down the flank thru Lennon and Crouch scored.
fantastic site, i’ve learned alot from this site, im glad it sticks to football and its not like other forums that get bogged down with incidents like gattusos carry on & flaminis tackle
Why he didn’t chose Ibrah as ST then Robinho and Pato on either side is beyond me…..Seedorf is so old and for him to be starting against the young legs of Spurs is suicide…he is not nearly as creative as Pirlo and lacks his former shot he once had…if Milan dont have Robinho,Pato,Ibra up front they will be smishmarted in the CL….their midfield is either way to old (gattuso,seedorf) or too in-experienced (merkel) or too inconsitant (flamini)……not to mention their full backs have zero attacking prowess the PATO/Ibrah/Robinho combo has been the only thing keeping them on top of the Serie A table…
i dont think i’ve ever been this nervous in one setting! omg! at least since February 15, 2005