Barcelona 3-1 Villarreal: open, exciting game

BARCELONA: 1 Valdes; 2 Alves, 5 Puyol, 22 Abidal, 19 Maxwell; 16 Busquets, 6 Xavi, 8 Iniesta; 17 Pedro, 10 Messi, 7 Villa. VILLARREAL: 13 D Lopez; 6 A Lopz, 5 Marchena, 4 Musacchio, 11 Capdevila; 21 Bruno, 20 Valero; 8 Cazorla, 10 Cani; 22 Rossi, 7 Nilmar. Usual diagrams back soon, probably next week...
Barcelona eventually passed their way past an excellent Villarreal side in a superb match at the Nou Camp.
Barcelona played their usual 4-3-3 shape. The major absentee was Gerard Pique, with Eric Abidal coming into the side alongside Carles Puyol.
Villarreal broadly stuck to their 4-2-2-2 system, last featured on ZM against Atletico Madrid. From that game there was a single change – Gonzalo Rodriguez was out, and young Argentine centre-back Mateo Musacchio was in.
The main feature here was simply the technical quality on show across the pitch, and the positive intent from both teams. Unlike a lot of sides visiting the Nou Camp, Villarreal did not sit back and only play on the counter-attack. They defended with two banks of four but frequently attacked with five players, Borja Valero joining the front four.
The game was played at a high tempo, both moved the ball quickly from back to front and switched play from flank to flank to change the point of attack. It was amongst the most fluid matches you will see in European football this year – no attacking player had a specific position, all had license to drift across the pitch and find space wherever they could.
Messi false nine
Of course, there were some set patterns, and Barcelona’s general shape was to play Pedro Rodriguez on the right, David Villa on the left and Lionel Messi in the centre of the pitch, as they have done for much of the season. Messi can play two separate roles in this position – either as a goalpoacher (not merely a goalpoacher, it should be said) who stays high up the pitch and looks to dart into space when the ball is played wide, or as a false nine, dropping into deeper positions and dragging the centre-backs with him.
It was the latter role he filled in the opening part of this match, and it was notable that Andres Iniesta and Xavi both played very high up the pitch, looking to exploit the space created by Messi’s reverse runs. With the full-backs pushing on and Busquets the player with most position discipline, it looked very much like the 2-3-2-3 as described by Jonathan Wilson when in possession – which was 70% of the time. Iniesta miscontrolled an early through ball and would have been one-on-one with Diego Lopez.
High pressing; high lines
Both sides were pressing high up the pitch – Barcelona were typically frantic when they lost the ball, seeking to regain it in the opposition half, but Villarreal also worked extremely hard in this sense. They closed down the Barcelona defenders at goal-kicks and Valero was alert to Busquets dropping deep to get out of the natural press of a 4-4-2 (or 4-2-2-2 in this case), but there was a slight problem in that Villarreal were often outnumbered in the centre of midfield, and one player, often Busquets, was afforded a lot of time on the ball.
Still, with both sides pressing, both were playing high lines, and there was ample space in behind both defences throughout the game. The best opportunities came from fairly simple balls over the top for onrushing attacking players – from Barcelona’s point of view, there was the Iniesta chance early on, then Villa opened the scoring in this fashion, then Pedro had a goal wrongly disallowed because of offside, all when the away side’s defensive line was caught out.
At the other end, twice in the game Barcelona conceded free-kicks inches from the penalty area when looking ragged at the back – Abidal and Maxwell the guilty parties. Villarreal’s goal, however, came from a solo run and finish from Nilmar.
Villarreal fluidity
The Brazilian forward has a good partnership with Giuseppe Rossi, although such is the nature of their positioning, they rarely combine directly. Often, when Villarreal won the ball, the two would place themselves in wide positions, stretching the Barcelona backline which was often deprived of Alves and/or Maxwell (who had gone forward to join the attack).
In turn, the interiores would drift inside to become central playmakers, and there was some confusion from Barcelona about how to deal with this. Busquets was effectively the spare man in all this and swept up in front of the defence, but Barcelona’s full-backs were not sure who to track – the forwards, or the interiores? Unlike against Atletico, the full-backs remained in relatively defensive roles, aware that leaving 3 v 3 at the back was unwise.
Messi goals
Indeed, even 6 v 2 wasn’t enough for Villarreal to prevent Barcelona’s astonishing third goal. A quickly-taken free-kick (similar to the first goal in El Clasico last season) from Xavi to Messi started the move, then two one-twos from Messi with Pedro playing ‘the wall’ resulted in Messi scampering past the entire defence, and chipping over Lopez.
That goal simply came down to pure wonderful football rather than tactics, but Villarreal were starting to tire – Cani, in particular, was having problems motoring up and down the line all game to stop Alves. The third goal again saw Pedro and Messi combine for a simpler goal, and Barcelona shut the game down well late on.
Conclusion
Some marvellous play from two excellent footballing sides. As well as Villarreal played, Barcelona were the better team and their triangles in midfield – particularly involving Iniesta and Xavi – were almost stereotypically good.
Villarreal were brave to come with their usual system and it’s unlikely that Juan Carlos Garrido will have any regrets in fielding it after an excellent performance, but the numerical disadvantage in midfield did mean they found it more difficult to win the ball back than Barcelona.
Barcelona 3-1 Villarreal: open, exciting game




Fabulous write-up, ZM, many thanks as always.
Has there ever been a player as devastating with the rapid-fire give-and-goes as Messi? His reaction time and dexterity with the ball in tight spaces is phenomenal.
It’s incredible. It seems like he’s started his run to get the return pass before he’s played the initial pass. Or something…
The brilliance of that goal required two impeccable world-class performances, and complete trust and understanding in each others abilities. The weight of Pedro’s first pass back to Messi was inch perfect. Messi chose to pass back to Pedro rather than hurdle the tackle, and Pedro’s redirection was again Xaviesque: perfectly seen, weighted and angled (rather than shooting or dribbling himself). Of course, Messi’s final run and chip finish was pure intuitive brilliance and skill.
Any two players with even slightly less ability, intimate understanding or trust would not have been able to pull it off. This is why we watch Barcelona.
Some of the one touch passing while Villareal were pressing them was unreal. Never scared to play a 2 yard pass and get it straight back anywhere on the pitch,
“It seems like he’s started his run to get the return pass before he’s played the initial pass.” – excellent ZM. I always had something like this in my mind, but didnt know how to put into words.
This one-twos happened in so tight spaces that this goal is among the very best in Europe, this season.
the second goal in the first CL match this season against Panathinaikos is just like this one, even more brilliant than this one. two 2on2,involving three, xavi,messi,pedro…check that..just magnificent.
I was going to quote this goal as well. That CL goal was pure masterpiece, the way they interchanged passes inches away from Panathinaikos players was incredible.
I thought Busquets had an excellent game, because he was often left isolated by the attacking intent of Xavi, Iniesta, Maxwell and Alves. He controlled much of the midfield, and Villarreal’s chances came when he was bypassed in the air. He is much more dynamic player than most people think (as is Xavi) and showed today why he is first choice over Mascherano
Indeed, he is an excellent passer when the ball is being pinged around in triangles and he receives it in tight spaces. He doesn’t need to take an extra touch, unlike Yaya Toure (which was why Guardiola was not heartbroken to see Yaya leave).
Just wondering ZM, do you play Football Manager 2011!? If you do, I reckon you’d have all the best and most effective tactics made straight away!!! Great read again… Messi shows that simple football can be the most effective!
Sadly not any more. Taking a break from ZM for CM/FM would be a bit too much tactics, even for me!
Some of the goals Barca score just make me laugh. They are ridiculously good at times, wonderful.
I get that laugh-inducing feeling too, as does Messi judging by his reaction to the first goal…
Haha. I was watching this in the living room and my grandma was there and every time anybody on Barcelona did something brilliant I would laugh because some of the things they can do are just ridiculous. Great game by Xavi by the way.
glad i’m not the only one laughing.
they’re just a joy to watch as a team. and then you’ve got messi who’s just on another planet. he’s going to break so many records. that guy can do anything in his career if he keeps his head together, which i don’t think will be a problem
I must commend Villareal for their offensive approach, but Barcelona’s pressing was magnificent. At one point, Villareal were pushed from the half-line all the way back into their own corner before they were forced to concede a throw-in. As ZM pointed out, Villareal also pressed hard, but Barca was able to play the ball out and up field while retaining possession. I also thought that Villareal, on the rare occasion that they did work the ball into the Barca third, were unable to find their teammates in good positions. I think the two forwards could have used more support from the attacking midfielders.
All in all, it was a superb match that I would recommend all to watch in full. Iniesta and Xavi were exceptionally excellent.
Best match I’ve seen in a long time.
This was probably the highest level of technical quality displayed so far this season in Europe.
ZM, about Nilmar and Rossi drifting out to the flanks when Villarreal had the ball; I recall two precedents for this.
1) France at World Cup 82 and Euro 84, when their two furthest men forward (Rocheteau and Six) were natural wingers, whilst slightly deeper Platini and Giresse were playing like Brazilian style playmakers – forming a U-shaped attack.
2) Atletico Madrid vs Liverpool in 2008 Champions League; Javier Aguirre instructed Sinama Pongolle and Diego Forlan to play wide and switch positions with the wide midfielders on their respective flanks (Simao and Luis Garcia) leaving a void in the middle… the difference with the Villarreal/France examples being that Atletico didn’t have advanced playmakers.
Wonderful to see your reference to that great French team of the 1980’s, Roberticus. I recall a few teams in the mid to late 1970’s playing 4-4-2 with the front 2 out wide. Dave Sexton wrote about facing a Dutch team using such a system when he was manager at QPR and the confusion it caused his defence.
Tam, if they were Dutch I’m not surprised…
I’ve seen Cruyff interviewed in English where describes 4-3-3 as “playing with three strikers”, so I guess that for the Dutch, a winger if used properly is truly a forward player. Therefore if that Dutch team in the late 70s simply discarded their centre-forward, they were still very much playing with two forwards.
great write up, best game of football i have seen this season, i have to commend villarreal for giving it a go, the skill & movement of players & both teams trying to win back the ball early was impressive, xavi & iniesta just dominate possession, reminds me of figo & rui costa around 2000
‘Indeed, even 6 v 2 wasn’t enough for Villarreal to prevent Barcelona’s astonishing third goal.’
ZM, should that be second goal instead of third? (Unless your including the perfectly legitimate offside goal they scored earlier..)
Other than that, brilliant read as always!
It was the third goal, just the second Barca goal.
Apologies, my bad.
Why hasn’t anyone tried playing a 4-4-2 with BOTH strikers playing as false 9s? Couldn’t it theoretically cause tons of trouble for the opposing defenders?
The Seattle Sounders of the MLS often did this during the last third of their season (whether intentionally or not I can’t say). It was great for possession and putting speedy wingers in on goal, not so good for getting goals for the strikers. Once they faced an opponent whose wide midfielders tracked back–it didn’t help that they were Donovan and Beckham, well above the usual MLS-level quality–it fell flat.
Man Utd have been doing it a bit when Dimitar and Chicha have been playing.
John,
check out that French team from the 1980s… Dominique Rocheteau and Didier Six (later Bellone) were all outside forwards..
villareal do this with rossi and neymar. check out some of zm’s articles on them
nilmar, not neymar.
Neymar is the young starlet for Santos, while Nilmar is the versatile striker that player for Villareal. I think Dunga preferred Nilmar because, although less gifted a dribbler, he is less elaborate and plays it simply and directly in attack.
That was an incredible goal, how do you defend against 2 players that can one-two their way past 6 of your players?
It really is in effect 2v3 (which makes it no less incredible).
Watch the video again several times, and watch what each defender does from start to finish. The main error is simply not defending for the quick start, which Barca has capitalized on time and time again. In this instance, Messi receives the ball with enough space to even take an outside shot. The centerback (Musacchio) is the first to realize what has happened and is forced to rush Messi to cut his angle.
The compounding error is the midfielder (Bruno) who jogs into the back line to cover when the Musacchio is forced to rush out to cover Messi. He is rather lackadaisical to a Messi threat (hello!?) and watches the ball on Pedro’s feet rather than guard against Messi’s attacking run. By the time he notices, Messi has already burst in front of him.
Forcing defensive errors, of course, is what good players do.
There are two spots of brilliance in particular that make this 2v3 succeed. The first is that Messi anticipates Bruno’s defense before Bruno does, and cuts back towards Pedro to receive the ball rather than run straight for goal. The second is where Pedro and Messi work the through pass- rather than on a diagonal directly towards the goal, it is placed away from the keeper and the defenders, almost perpendicular to the goal line. This buys time for Messi to run onto the ball with a few yards space so he can get off a shot unimpeded.
Excellent points, but I guess from a manager’s point of view you can only set your team up to cover the dangerous areas, there wasn’t much you could do in this case.
Thanks ZM. Brilliant as always. This was the game of the season for me. All respect to Villareal for giving real tense moments to Barca. But seriously, I am not sure they would have equalised if that second goal would have been allowed. I felt the whole Barca team lost their concentration for a moment and Nilmar made the best use of it with his speed. He is going to be a star, sure.
I am glad that I am alive to see this match, especially the first goal from Messi. This goal is an ambassador for the beuatiful game.
In fact they lost concentration for the rest of the half, during which Villareal was the more dangerous team. Just a terrible decision by the referee, but it allowed the match to stay entertaining to the end. So there’s that.
i think you’d have to point the blame at the linesman for that one, not the ref.
This Barcelona system is so fascinating, especially the defensive line and Busquets’ role. One thing I noticed on multiple occasions during this match was how big the gap was between Puyol and Abidal when Busquets drops back. Also, Dani Alves was moving into the centre of the pitch a lot more than usual with Puyol taking up position between CB and RB to cover for him and a similar thing was happening on the opposite side with Abidal and Maxwell. Between those 4 + Busquets, 6 positions were being covered, essentially giving Barcelona and “extra man” so to speak.
We are lucky that we live in an age where we can watch a team like Barcelona week in week out. After watching the turgid Mancunian derby and the sterile tactics of both City and United, Barcelona v Villarreal was like a breath of fresh air. Some of the passages of play were incredible. The likes of Messi, Iniesta and even Giuseppe Rossi are so good at receiving the ball in tight areas they look as though they could find time and space in a phone box!
On a tactical note, I am already looking forward to El Classico in a couple of weeks. The most intriguing battle will be Alves v Ronaldo. Alves is a brilliant attacking right back but can at times leave gaping holes which can be exploited (as Villarreal did on a few occasions). Ronaldo has no interest in tracking back the right full-back when he plays on the left of the band of three and therefore will probably be looking to exploit the space vacated by Alves on counter atttacks. The left side of Real Madrid and right side of Barcelona will possibly hold the key to outcome of the match.
But the Premiership is the best league in the world, Kevin.
I know this for a fact because Richard Keys and Andy Gray tell us so every week…
I gave up listening to Andy Gray a long time ago. Just listen to the tactical analysis of Gray both during live games, the Super Sunday final word and pre-match on the Monday night football. He has not played or coached for nearly 20 years and his tactical analysis of games is like listening to a time warp from the 1980s. Modern tactics like having more than 3 playing bands, false number nines, inverted wingers etc, etc are entirely alien concepts to a man who has been brought up on a diet of 4-4-2, big man/little man front pairings.
In my opinion, Gray has had his day and Sky should look to replace him with someone more in touch with the game in 2010.
1) ZM is probably the only place on internet where post-game report from that match doesn’t mention horribly refereeing, even for La Liga standards (which are quite low IMO) referee had a shocker. Impressive.
2) Somebody mentioned Barcelona’pressing being so succesfull a few times, that Villarreal was backed down in their own box trying to play out of trouble. But two or three times there was a opposite situation – Barca’s full backs pushed forward, leaving centre backs to play the ball from their area. They were pressed by Rossi/Nilmar and then Busquets was dropping back, but his run was covered by one of the interiores. Then it was Xavi who decided to drop back, yet again – he was covered again by 2nd of the interiores. So ball had to be played back to Valdes, who had to hoof it, looking very surprised that he was asked to do it that way.
Really good performance by Villarreal and I really hope they will qualify for CL, but Barca last night was just too good.
Btw – if Senna would be fit to play, would he replace Cani or Borja in starting line-up?
Interesting Stinger,
I wonder if Mourinho will imitate this addressive strategy in the clasico.
But something tells me he is more comfortable defending deep vs Barcelona – considering how this was the way he beat them last year.
Mourinho didn’t defend deep against barca when he beat them last year (e.g at the san siro). He pushed the defence up and pressed barca high up the pitch, giving them little time on the ball and as a consequence barca created few chances
I refer to the Camp Nou game, since that is where Madrid will be visiting.
Then he was notably more cautious.
Also with Chelsea in both games in 2004-05 and 05-06
But he lost that match 1-0 and it really should have been 2 or even 3-0 if not for a very questionable handball called against Toure and Bojan blowing an open net header.
and his objective was to protect a 3-1 aggregate lead, different circumstances this time around. Im confident he will press barca high up the pitch rather than sit the likes of ronaldo and di maria in his own half inviting pressure
Agree with you, 3rnaldo. If you watch the first leg of the CL between Inter-Barca last spring the Inter pressing clearly discomfited Barca. If RM has the work ethic to attempt it I’ve no doubt they’ll try the same. Plus it puts CR, Higuain et.al., in better positions for counters.
Will be interesting to see if Carlos Puyol can summon the same type of game he had in Round 1 of El Clasico last year. Kept Barca in the match versus furious RM forays until Barca found it’s rhythm. A masterpiece of defending, that.
Roberticus – we’ll see. Mourinho probably would have to use front 4 players for this to work, but it would require high discipline from Khedira and Alonso to make sure, that Barca wouldn’t had 2 on 1 situation on the flanks, with possibility of full backs combining with outside forwards. Of course, only if Barca would somehow beat that kind of pressing.
True Stinger,
and a high-defensive line is always risky against a pacey trio of Messi, Villa and Pedro. Which makes me think Mourinho will go with his tried and trusted method… maybe not exactly the “give Barcelona the ball” approach of last year, but still play quite deep try to hit them on the counter.
Perhaps the worst approach would be to replicate Juande Ramos’ “neither-fish-nor-foul” strategy during the 2-6 at the Bernabeu; Madrid played a high defensive line but with none of the concommittant pressing in midfield or attack.
Since we’re discussing here – really enjoy reading your blog as well, loved article regarding Villarreal, as well the one about Mano’s ideas for Brazil.
I agree with your 2nd point. There were times, during Villareal’s pressing, that Valdes stood there for like 5 seconds with the ball and not knowing who to pass because everyone was covered. But I do think that Valdes plays well and has confidence with his feet, so i am not surprise by this.
and what about the card for BARCA player when he was the last man? Yes it was yellow. It was deliberate cheating by the referee.
yawn
Having been at the game in the Camp Nou, I can say that you have pretty much nailed it, ZM.
Question: How do you manage to analyze the role of Busquets and other DMs so well while watching on TV? (Or were you the guy sitting behind me in the stadium narrating the whole game in Catalan?) On TV, the camera always cuts off the back line and DMs when a team is attacking, whereas in person you can really see the movement and space between all the players on the field and the magic that a player like Busquets provides. I remember seeing a fantastic diagram that you made of Barca’s positional movement between defending and attacking where Busquets drops back and the wingbacks go forward, but when watching on TV I could never really see the space that it created for Busquets, Alves and Maxwell like I could in person. It really is a joy to behold, though, regardless of where you watch it.
When watching game try to watch movement and positioning of player when he do have the ball and when he doesn’t
:) You can see everything.
After watching Barça play for so long I have to say it’s turned my enjoyment of the game on its head. If a side can’t play with that pinball-like wizardry that Barcelona invoke, why bother? The Catalan club has ruined me. At least there’s the Yellow Submarine as well. A great match.
When I see Iniesta and Xavi in the middle and Messi between the lines, I am calm. Villa instead of Ibrahimovic allows Barca more fluidity, and more movement when they have the ball. They often play 2 4 1 3 or 2 3 2 2 or 2 3 2 3. With movement of forward 3 players they can confuse any defence, in addition, Villa is up to his best again, Messi is better (in my opinion) in false nine role than on flank, and Barca is looking better to me than last year.
Since everyone is not looking ahead to el clasico, i’d like to get my two cents in. I think the key tactical matchups are Ronaldo vs Alves on the left flank, and the conflict between the midfield three’s. I think Ozil will struggle to find space against the marking of Busquets (like in the semifinal) and Barca’s three will control possession. It won’t be a lopsided control however, because Khedira is comfortable tracking Xavi both deep and higher up the pitch (a major reason Mourinho signed him). Barca can invert their trio, as can madrid, meaning there will be little space there. However, Alonso’s poise on the ball may be able to break Barca’s press a few times, leading to quick balls to Ronaldo/Di Maria on the wings, where Barca’s attacking fullbacks could be vulnerable. I don’t think Barca’s fullbacks will be quite as cavalier as usual, so Barca’s wide men will have to get wider in attack. Its going to be a tight game, with fewer chances than usual for both teams. finishing will be paramount, so the result is unpredictable.
left flank= Madrid’s left, Barca’s right
Last Clasico, Pep did a rather exciting formation. He put Puyol as a RB and moved D.Alves as a RW. He knows that Dani’s space can be exploited by the likes of Ronaldo and he compensated by leaving Puyol back there and guard that space. Alves wasn’t pleased with his position -his performance wasn’t great there either- but it was a precaution that Pep took.
The way Abidal played last night I don’t think he will want to move Puyol out of the center of defense this time, perhaps if Milito is fit by then.
Under Pellegrini, Villarael had an alternative 4231 system they used when they played against Barcelona. It was very successful and he had more wins than losses against them. The alternative system is more solid defensively but still allows the attacking players to express themselves. If Garrido is copying the Pellegrini blueprint then he should copy the pragmatism as well.
Copenhagen were recently able to stifle Barcelona by having a withdrawn striker man marking Busquets. Hercules did the same thing. Why arent other teams taking the hint ?
Barcelona are more 3313 than 2323 in shape
A good resume of what it’s been said here is that great compilation of Barcelona’s “tiki-taka” against Villareal. Surreal at times… http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5pJFC7hb-sY
matt, well done talking about “el clásico”.
A good analysis of a impressive match. You really have to respect Villareal’s attacking intent. They did not sit back but came to ‘play’ the game and they took it to Barca. But as is obvious, when you fight fire with fire against Barca. you always lose. Especially at the Camp Nou. Even our friend Jose Mourinho know that. I think Real will be looking to hit Barca on the counter in el clasico. They have the perfect players to do this like Ronaldo, Di Maria, etc. The game will be won in midfield. Compared to previous seasons, Real is much more organised and the defensive pairing of Carvalho and Pep is stable. I think it will be a tight game.
An interesting game, great stuff ZM.
Did anyone find that Villareal’s passing game became somewhat foolhardy or even foolish? Admittedly I missed the start of the game, when they played their best football, but in the second half they often lost possession when struggling to patiently pass the ball out. The reason being, of course, that Barca are probably (almost certainly) the most aggressive and best pressing team in the game.
This was compounded by Villareal’s poor long (or at least more direct) game. The strikers rarely looked ready to recive longer passes, the passing was often straight rather than angled, the strikers didn’t work in tandem to trap the ball in an opposition zone and they were outmatched physically.
In truth, Villareal would have been better served if one of the strikers had dropped into midfield, or indeed was replaced by a midfielder. It benefits the team little to have two strikers on if they are both isolated. From the start of the second half Barca were so dominant that it was only a matter of time before fatigue resulted in a mistake – such as turning off at a set-piece – and a goal.
On the occasions that Villareal did get the ball to their attackers they continued to look a threat. Abidal (especially at CB) and Maxwell are weak spots. Of course, it may have been a different story if Maxwell had been (rightly, I think) red carded, but the second half allowed Barca to play the way they wanted to. Hercules were a blueprint for playing the champions, it would be more difficult for them to retain the title if more teams followed that lead.
http://www.zonalmarking.net/2010/09/14/barcelona-0-2-hercules-tactics-nelson-valdez/
I have to disagree on Villarreal’s threat, in theory it’s true that Abidal (as CB) isn’t quite convincing but in this game there were probably 5 occasions that Villarreal tried to bring the ball up from their right side (Barca’s left) but over and over again Abidal and Maxwell got it covered.
Yes, they manage to bring the ball to the final third but always ended up losing the ball. I found it amazing how well Abidal managed to pass and control the ball even when he was closely pressed. However, I still believe that in occasion he was playing as if he was a LB.
What are your thoughts on Maxwell? He was always good on Football Manager a few years ago – not a valid sign of whether he’s that good in real life, admitedly, but still, he seemed to falter a little and never really went on to become the world class fullback I thought he might. But then Barca signed him, so he must be OK. Is he a useful attacking force or merely a good foil to Alves on the other flank?
Barca’s formation is still a bit asymmetric, with D Alves getting further forward, but the signing of Maxwell was a step towards greater width and ability on the left flank.
He started well at Inter, although he was sometimes used in the midfield instead and Mourinho certainly didn’t like him at left-back. It is a bit strange that he was never really a contender for left back at the world cup for Brazil – unless there is something I’m missing. Altogether, he doesn’t seem to be the strongest defensively. I remember Walcott scoring for Arsenal against Barca (with Maxwell at left back) last season and generally that looked the most promising area for Arsenal to attack.
Being a full back at Barca is a tough job though. As with many teams who play inverted wingers, it must be exhausting providing a constant source of width. Generally, Maxwell seems to do alright, but I would still say he is one of the weakest links in the team. I think the Depor left back Filipe was Barca’s first choice when they were looking for a full back.
I think the signing of Adriano Correia was meant to provide a double back-up for either Alves or Maxwell in terms of a flying wing-back
That transfer was a bit depressing. Just look at the impact Drenthe is having, while Canales and the Diarras are at Madrid doing nothing; Adriano was very important for Sevilla but he joins Macherano on the bench. Bit of a shame.
Obviously to compete on all fronts you need a squad capable of withstanding injuries and fatigue, but the distribution of resources is far from optimal.
Very true. A lot of young players do seem to leave clubs too early, hard to resist the calls of Barca and Real though.
Mascherano transfer was weird… I really don’t know why did he decided to join Barca even tho he KNEW that he would be on the bench. But I do have to agree that he has been playing much better in comparison with the earlier games. For Barca is a plus! but for him i am not sure.
Kevos,
I think you are right to an extent. Villareal really struggled in the second half to get their players into dangerous positions or, more specifically, to get their attacking players into space. As a result of the pressure Villareal players were under when they received the ball, Barcelona, Abidal and Maxwell included, were able to deal with most of what came their way. A lot of the longer passes, as I said, were poorly executed and were fairly routine to defend
However, I noticed that when they did have the ball in advanced positions options appeared for Villareal. Rossi in particular was guilty of not relaeasing the ball quickly enough, opting to move into defenders rather than passing. What Villareal did do well was to get runners forward. Furthermore, Maxwell should have been sent off as Villareal broke through on goal.
Barca, like Spain, can be hit by somewhat direct attacks that take advantage of the space they leave in behind. Barca’s CBs do tend to become FBs as the defence splits (though often with Busquets dropping in) which can leave them isolated. Their supremacy further forwards masks a sometimes vulnerable defence. However, splitting the field into attack and defence is to miss the point, Barca press high, suffocating sides. Of course there is space in behind, but Villareal often couldn’t find it.