ZM’s European Team of the Season
With only one game left of the 2009/10 season, it’s time to create that inevitable, impossible-to-please dream team from across the major European leagues.
Playing in a fluid 4-3-3 / 4-2-3-1 system that remains the most popular formation throughout Europe, it also reflects the current emphasis upon centre-backs who can pass the ball, attacking full-backs, ball-playing central midfielders and versatile attacking players.
Goalkeeper:
Pepe Reina, Liverpool
It’s remarkable that any Liverpool player has managed to emerge from this season with their reputation enhanced, but Reina has saved Liverpool from yet more misery on countless occasions. Whilst his season will probably be remembered solely for the unfortunate/hilarious ‘beach ball’ goal at Sunderland, he still managed to keep the (joint) highest-number of clean sheets in the Premiership, for the fourth time in his five Premiership seasons. Incredibly, despite this record he has still never got into the PFA Team of the Year, suggesting that despite his consistent individual brilliance, he remains underappreciated. Have some of his best saves from 2009:
Right-back:
Daniel Alves, Barcelona
It is often assumed that full-backs who attack constantly are also weak defenders, a tag that seems to have been given to Alves. But he’s consistently shown he is more than a competent right-back defensively, rarely being beaten on his own flank, and covering his full-backs well from balls over the top from the left. Rarely has any footballer possessed such speed and stamina, and Alves is as close as any footballer has come to being able to play in two positions at once, right-back and right-wing, once Messi has drifted inside. And when he does get forward, he can do things like this:
Centre-back:
Lucio, Inter
Quite possibly the signing of the season. Getting Brazil’s captain at a knock-down rate last summer was one of the best pieces of business Jose Mourinho has done since leaving Portugal, as Lucio has formed a mildly terrifying partnership with another South American veteran, Walter Samuel. Lucio is remarkably unconventional for a top-notch defender – whereas many of his class are calm, assured players who read the game well and look to be playing it at a stroll, Lucio is a rugged, dramatic player who seems to want to exaggerate every tackle, clearance and coming-together with an opponent. Everything Lucio does is the outfield equivalent of a goalkeeper’s ’save for the cameras’. Regardless, when it comes to the pure nitty-gritty of defending, he is one of the world’s best and has had a tremendous first season with Inter. The way he handled Didier Drogba against Chelsea was particularly impressive:
Centre-back:
Gerard Pique, Barcelona
If Lucio is a throwback to the brutal South American defenders of years gone by, Pique is every inch the modern centre-back. Able to bring the ball forward as well as spread to the flanks to widen the pitch, Pique is also excellent defensively and his reading of the game is superb. Last season’s Champions League final against his former seemed to be a watershed moment for Pique – transforming from a decent centre-back to a world class one, and he’s continued that form this season. How many other centre-backs could score this goal?
.
Left-back:
John Arne Riise, Roma
Many thought Riise’s career as a top-level player was over when he was forced out of Anfield by Rafael Benitez, but this season’s form has shown he still has a few years left in him yet. Perhaps the key to his rejuvenation as a player was finding a club that suits his playing style. At Roma he does not merely have a license to get forward, he has strict instructions to get forward – with their left-sided attacking width coming from Mirko Vucinic, their main striker, Riise overlapping is important to allow Vucinic to cut in and offer a goal threat. He has made one or two mistakes when defending at the far post, but has made up for them with some crucial goals, such as against Juventus:
Central midfield:
David Pizarro, Roma
Is this man Europe’s most underrated footballer? Few players can control a game as completely as Pizarro can, and he was vital in Roma’s near-triumphant return from the dead. Pizarro is essentially an Andrea Pirlo-style deep playmaker, sitting infront of the defence and spraying passes around the pitch. But whereas Pirlo often seems unconvincing when forced to take on a slightly more defensive role, Pizarro is a more complete midfielder, battling to win the ball before keeping hold of it expertly. There is no better footballer that will be absent from this year’s World Cup. Check out the tackle and cross for Riise’s goal above, and here’s highlights of his performance against Fiorentina this season:
Central midfield:
Xavi Hernandez, Barcelona
Two seasons in a row, Xavi has dominated the biggest club game in Europe at the Bernabeu. Four assists last season in the 2-6, both assists this season in the 0-2. And it would have been more, had Lionel Messi not missed two fairly basic one-on-ones with Iker Casillas. He is probably the most reliable, consistent passer of the ball in the world, and ZM’s passing statistics for Barcelona games generally resulted in a ludicrous dominance from Barcelona’s vice-captain (see here, here and here. Now aged 30, he continues to get better and better. Here’s his two assists at the Bernabeu:
.
Attacking midfield:

Wesley Sneijder, Inter
There can be few players in Sneijder’s position who have adapted so quickly to a new league. From the first game of the season, where he helped inspire Inter to a 0-4 victory over Milan, it was clear that he was to be Inter’s main man this season. Whilst the trequartista role has declined in popularity in recent years, Sneijder thrived in that advanced position behind two strikers, whilst also able to play a slightly deeper position, sometimes in a 4-2-4 when Inter went chasing games. His passing ability in open play, his direct running and his free-kick ability make him a wonderful player to watch, and a very difficult one to stop. Against Chelsea at Stamford Bridge he dominated the game and it was fitting that Inter won the game after a superb Sneijder through-ball:
Forward:
Arjen Robben, Bayern
Another Dutchman chucked out by Real Madrid last summer, Arjen Robben has been the Bundesliga player of the year, and had a vital impact in Bayern Munich’s run to the European Cup final too. His ‘winners’ against Fiorentina and against Manchester United were two of the goals of the tournament in terms of pure technical quality, and even better considering the importance of both. Robben has generally stuck to the right-hand side in Bayern’s fluid 4-4-2 / 4-2-3-1 system, cutting onto his stronger left foot to score 16 goals in 24 league games, and is therefore the posterboy for the recent popularity of inverted wingers. Now a Champion in four different countries – Holland, England, Spain and Germany – Robben is playing for the first time as the key player at a top club, and is playing his best-ever football as a result. The Fiorentina and Manchester United goals have been played non-stop in recent months, so how about his incredible winner in the German Cup semi-final against Schalke:
Forward:
Lionel Messi, Barcelona
Inclusion into the band of all-time greats might have to wait until he has performed brilliantly on the international stage, but Messi’s form over the past two seasons has already elevated him to the best footballer of this century. The most immediate comparison there is to Zinedine Zidane, but for all the Frenchman’s moments of magic, at no stage in his career did he play football as consistently well as in Messi’s last two seasons. Able to play wide-right, as a central playmaker or as false nine, specific position doesn’t seem to matter for Messi. His record of 34 league goals equals Ronaldo’s legendary record of 1996/97, and having played two games fewer and further from goal, Messi’s record is probably even more incredible. He is still only 22. Here’s his hattrick against Valencia:
Forward:
Wayne Rooney, Manchester United
Many in England protested that Wayne Rooney was being played out of position for the past couple of seasons when he often featured on the left flank, allowing Cristiano Ronaldo more of a forward role. The consensus, however, was that his ‘true’ position was as a deep-lying forward, creating chances more than finishing them. It’s a surprise to most, therefore, that he has played the best football of his career as an out-and-out striker, a poacher inside the 18-yard box – it’s not long since he was given the ‘a scorer of great goals, but not a great goalscorer’ tag. Rooney has actually played three distinct roles this season upfront. Firstly, in a 4-4-2 as an out-and-out striker who looks to link with Dimitar Berbatov, his strike partner, who plays slightly deeper. Secondly, as a lone striker playing purely as a ‘poacher’ in games United dominate possession in, in a vaguely similar way Ruud van Nistelrooy used to. Thirdly, also playing as a lone striker but playing as a false nine – dropping deep and looking to create space for midfield runners, like against Arsenal. Like Messi, Sneijder (and Cristiano Ronaldo) Rooney is proving that the very best attacking players can play well in a variety of roles. His goal away at Arsenal showed the value of the false nine role brilliantly:
ZM’s European Team of the Season




Reserve XI:
Victor Valdes, Barcelona
Far from the nervous, shakey keeper of old, Valdes has been superb this season, the first time in years that Barcelona have had a top-class goalkeeper.
Branislav Ivanovic, Chelsea
Not a natural right-back by any means, but defensively he is one of the best around. Physically excellent and positionally aware, he is rightly a fan favourite at Stamford Bridge.
Alessandro Nesta, Milan
Before his injury problems, Nesta looked like he was the Nesta of old – cool, calm, composed and always in the right place at the right time.
Walter Samuel, Inter
Alongside Lucio, he formed a brilliant central defensive partnership that many predicted would be too old and slow to cope in Europe – they proved the doubters wrong.
Ashley Cole
He is universally loathed off the pitch but should be universally admired on it. Started the season excellently and would be in the first XI were it not for his mid-season injury, which he has recovered from remarkably quickly.
Esteban Cambiasso
How can Maradona have left him out of Argentina’s World Cup squad? The most reliable holding player a manager could ever wish for.
Cesc Fabregas
His best season yet in an Arsenal shirt, and perhaps his last. An increasingly advanced role seemed to suit him well.
Frank Lampard
Only started to play his best football towards the end of the season, but demonstrated that there are no better goalscoring central midfielders around.
Cristiano Ronaldo
A tremendous first season for Real, and amazingly for a £80m player, probably value for money. Only pushed out because of the brilliance of the attacking four in the first XI, but could have easily been in ahead of Rooney.
Didier Drogba
Whilst he can’t get knocked out of the Champions League without embarrassing himself, he continues to dominate the Premiership, and won his second Golden Boot award.
Diego Milito
Narrowly beats Gonzalo Higuain and Antonio di Natale to a place on the bench. Scored a shedload of goals, but more importantly, scored a hell of a lot of crucial goals, including the winner in the Coppa Italia final and the winner on the final day of the league season.
Cool point about Valdes. So he has improved and got the Zamora trophy and all. But what about Cech and Casillas? They have been better than Valdes. But cant argue since this is your list. Wish you would have included CR9 and Drogba in the starting line-up. Finally someone has noticed Lucio. Good choice- the man has been excellent.
Cech was good, though still not as good as he was before the injury. Casillas had a pretty bad season by his standards, fortunately he improved in the latter part of it, fortunately for Spain team of course.
I wouldn’t pick Cech, because he seems to be poor at organizing a defense for corners and so on.
cech won the golden gloves for this season not reina.
drogba scored more and assisted more then rooney, where is maicon?
Wrong, ish
Reina tied the Golden Gloves with Cech on 17 clean sheets. Please get your facts right before you post.
cech had same clean sheets in less games so he won it, please get your facts straight before you post.
Casillas definitely had a poor year for him, letting in goals you expect him to save. Valdes played better than him this season (and has reached top form), and deserves the recognition. Nice to see him make the Spanish team, as a backup, as well.
I believe the back-up keeper is Reina? Is Valdes in the squad too?
great choice on reina. constantly overlooked.
Two very good teams, not many qualms with either. I’d have put Ashley Cole in ahead of Riise though. I know you mention that he would have been in barring the injury, but I think he still did enough to warrant a place in the first eleven. Cashley’s an idiot, but he’s the best left back in the World right now, and for most of the season he was sensational.
As for Cristiano Ronaldo, I’m surprised there hasn’t been room for him somewhere; as you say, he has probably justified his price tag. But I suppose one could criticise him for not being a true team player; it often seems as if he’s playing for personal rather than collective glory.
Not seen enough of Pizarro to comment, but as for the rest of the team, spot on. Sneijder and Lucio have been revelations. I think Lucio has been the best centre back in the World and Sneijder is, as you suggest, a throwback to the classic playmaker and a joy to watch this season.
Reina impressed this season, I don’t mind seeing him in the dream team. As for the Valdes: he improved a lot from his shady past, but this season I’d put Julio Cesar over him. He was great this season and his team, although great at defence too, gave him a bit more occasions to shine than Barca to Valdes.
Sorry, but where in God’s name is Maicon? He should be in the starting line-up if you ask me since Dani Alves was underperforming for the two-three first months of the season. And how did Robben end up in the starting line-up before CR9?
Maicon hasn’t been great for a few seasons now, frankly.
Robben took his team to the CL finals; CR9 crashed out against a French team. They both scored loads of goals.
Either you don’t know what you’re talking about or you haven’t seen Maicon. This is probably his best season to date. Dani Alves was downright BAD the first three months of the season. Robben took his team to the CL final? Was it Robben or Ovrebo? Bayern were lucky to get to the final and I’m not trying to take anything away from Robben. I love Robben, and I hope that Bayern win the final for Robben’s sake but not putting Ronaldo ahead of Robben is almost disrespectful. First of all, CR9 scored more goals in the CL in less games than Robben and he also scored in the game against “a French” team. Ronaldo finished the season scoring 33 goals and with, I think, 7 assists. In 35 games (of which he was a substitute in two or three) he scored 33 goals. Had he not been injured for two months he would surely have scored 40+ goals. Ronaldo is a far better and versatile player than Robben is.
“Not putting Ronaldo ahead of Robben is almost disrespectful.”
Of course it’s not, it’s an opinion for heaven’s sake. Either way no-one is saying Ronaldo hasn’t had a great season, but Robben has been by far the best player in a team that won the domestic league, the domestic cup, and is in the Champions League final. He also scored the winning goal in two of Bayern’s three knockout ties, and got the crucial first goal in the other.
Ronaldo’s stats are impressive but hasn’t changed the biggest games he’s played in – Robben has.
hey, evra has been a full notch above cole ( especially considering he has been injury plagued ) and riise, the only consistent in a injury-ridden united defence. easily the most consistent attacking left back in the world.
a full notch how? in goals scored? assists? what has evra done this season that cole didnt better?
keeping his own wife ? :-S
just kidding…
Posted by a Man Utd fan, methinks.
Great player though he is, Evra is vastly over-rated offensively. Only 3 league assists this season, 2 last season (admittedly hampered by injury), and just one assist in 2007-08. Two of those seasons Man Utd won the league.
Fail to see how stats like that qualify him as “easily the most consistent attacking left back in the world”. Surely a world-class attacking LB would score more than that.
In comparison, Leighton Baines has a goal and 9 assists, and even Gareth Bale has 3 goals and 5 assists in half as many games.
i would pick vidic instead of nesta thats for sure.
ashley cole’s easily been better than riise, and evra too.
good job appreciating pizarro, he’s played very well. don’t disagree much with anything else.
I love Pizarro too, definitely the playmaking heart of his team, the way Xavi and Sneijder are for theirs. Of the three, he’s also the toughest and the best defender.
putting aside the team, ashley cole has played better than riise this season
however, taking into account team tactics, riise is more important for roma than cole is for chelsea, even if cole is the better player. riise’s bombarding runs forward allows vucinic to cut in. riise has started every league game for roma this season minus 1. thats how important he is
Indeed, a large part of why he’s in. Cole has probably performed better in the games he’s featured in, but he did miss almost three months through injury, so hard to include him.
why does that matter? filipe has been more important for deportivo than most players mentioned here, including each of the left backs.
but performances are what counts, not importance. although filipe has been sensational too, to be fair.
in fact, i’d choose drogba over rooney too, better performances against other top clubs in the league, quite easily too i’m pretty sure.
but he’s been more ‘important’ for united – so what?
I’d put in a shout for Felipe at LB as well.
Everyone get’s their own opinion but there is no way Drogba’s season was better than Rooney’s.
The most obvious point to make is Chelsea played great with or without Drogba, but on the flipside Manchester United looked lost without Rooney. Sure Drogba performed great but he simply wasn’t crucial to Chelsea’s play. Chelsea also as a team simply scored more often than united: 103 compared to 86.
Drogba has also been noted on this site as having suspect link-up play: http://www.zonalmarking.net/2010/04/17/tottenham-2-1-chelsea-tactics/
Rooney also did more defensively than Drogba but can anyone really expect Drogba at age 32 to have a work rate as high as Rooney?
All that aside ‘god’ (not pretentious at all) a players importance to a team does matter. It matters a lot. The most important statistic is wins (points) and a players overall contribution to his team winning can’t be ignored.
Again Drogba played great and he’s certainly worthy of a spot on the bench but, love him or hate him, Rooney was the best premier league striker this year.
sorry ltjbr i’ll run it past you next time what i call myself shall i?
1/ spurs-chelsea: er, yeah one bad game certainly means drogba has worse link up play despite having twice as many as assists as rooney
2/ so what if he did more defensively? we’re considering a striker spot right?
3/ of course importance to a team / points matters, but what i’m arguing his performances matter more.
in any case they were both fantastic obviously and it’s tight but the defining factor for me is that drogba was just too pivotal against the top sides for me.
Drogba was carrying an injury in the match at WHL… he was clearly not right at the start of the second half.
Why do you think Rooney did more defensively? Next time you watch Chelsea, see how many times Drogba gets to the ball first in the Chelsea penalty area from opposition set-pieces. Thats his role defensively and he does it extremely effectively
bleh, no point arguing with obvious Chelsea fans, no chance of listening to reason and 100% intolerant of opposing viewpoints. particularly angry ones like ‘not god’. But yes, defensive ability does matter from forward positions. It’s been the deciding factor in many matches ZM has covered.
Oliver, It’s common practice for tall strikers to go back and help defend on set-peaces so in this regard what drogba does is relatively routine. Besides, it’s not that he does a bad job defending, he actually does well, just not as well.
At any rate, not sure if the best striker was European striker was Rooney, but given the choice between Rooney and Drogba: Tough choice but I think ZM got it right.
i’m a spurs fan
also not sure where you’re reading me be angry exactly? apart from your pathetic little comments about ‘god’ which i’ve not responded well too yes, but i’m not especially ‘angered’ about drogba vs rooney, i appreciate both but as i’ve said, his performances in the bigger games mean i rate him having a better year considering he’s also scored more, assisted more- etc. but it’s hardly something infuriating if someone thinks rooney, who also had a world class season to be better eh?
Maicon?
i thought that he had a better season than Dani Alves especially in the chamions league match against Barce.
I think in general, Maicon > Alves, don’t think Maicon has had his best season though.
maicon had his best season this year. he had more goals and assists than alves this season
he’s also more defensively sound than alves IMO. he’s stronger physically too
maicon and ivanovic should definitely be the top RB’s this year. dani alves 3rd unless i’m forgetting another key RB
I tend to disagree about this being Maicon’s best year, he took a while to get into his top form this year and even then I thought he was better at his best last year.
Goals and assists are good stats, but they aren’t really the best way to determine between full backs. Fullbacks tend to get their assists off crosses, which Inter do a lot more than Barca. Alves’ best contributions come when he does what no other fullback really does consistently, he joins the attack and, crucially, stays in the attack.
A lot of attacking fullbacks bomb forward, hit a cross, and that is that, it’s a proven style and it’s not a knock on anybody to say that is what they do; Alves though usually makes his run, and participates in the build up with several passes, holding his wide position, occupying a defender, and freeing up the forwards.
Maicon has all those qualities too. This guy is the entire right flank of Inter. He isn’t just a ball crosser. He starts, orchestrates and often ends the attack too. Look at his goals against udinese or barcelona.
Participates in buildup with several passes? Check
Occupying a defender or two? Check
Freeing up forwards? Check. Look at etoo hes free as a dove.
Defends better than Alves? Check.
And I think he does all that pretty consistently. Even in his dodgy first half of the season, he was doing all of the above. The only difference was that his final ball was unusually poor. Another reason for that had to do with mourinhos diamond system which really limited inters width on the left side, thus allowing defences to focus on crowding maicon out.
The left side being closed up is a pretty good point; Zanetti was forced back into playing left back a lot, where I think he is now more suited to a cultured midfield role
As usual, everyone overlooks Philipp Lahm and his overall importance to a Bayern side on the brink of a treble. Lahm has played every single minute of every single match for bayern this season, bar one, where he was suspended.
And ofcourse as usual, people will talk about the incredible achievements of Robben without for once mentioning how big a role Lahm has played in this, that too in his first season as a right-back.
I challenge you to find such an intelligent, ball playing full back, in world football today, Dani Alves included (overall dynamism excluded).
Maicon. done.
i think that there is generally a “favouritism” towards players like Alves, Ronaldo, Messi, ferdinand etc where people think that they have an aura around them and they always seem to end up in the team of the season, eventhough there might have been a better player who isnt as well known. i think a good example of this is henry after he left arsenal and everyone was saying how he was one of he best players in the world during that season, eventhough he struggled.
Maicon had a better season than Alves and is a better player, in my opinion obviously, but Alves is a solid choice too.
That said Maicon is and has been this season a whole league ahead of Ivanovic.
It’s close. But why did ZM post Alves’ botched cross as a highlight?
Wonderful, spot-on characterization of Lucio — he ought to put that on his tombstone.
No Maicon seriously ? He is should be 1st right back with Alves on reserve. Maicon is better defender and a great threat offensively. Plus he scores wonder goals too
Can’t disagree with much of that, beyond definitely having Evra and Cole in ahead of Riise. One minor quibble – Petr Cech actually won the Golden Gloves award. Same number of clean sheets as Reina, but in less games.
Interesting – is that official? Benitez and Reina seem to be celebrating it!
http://www.dailypost.co.uk/sport-news/liverpool-fc/2010/05/19/liverpool-fc-s-golden-gloves-pepe-reina-praised-by-rafa-benitez-55578-26473771/
I can’t get that link to load for some reason, but the official premier league website has an article here – http://www.premierleague.com/page/Headlines/0,,12306~2051839,00.html – about Cech winning it.
They shared the award:
http://bleacherreport.com/articles/390101-petr-cech-and-jose-reina-share-barclays-golden-glove-award
awww how sweet =D
Does that mean they got a glove each?
Cech actually won it as his clean sheet to games ratio was better. there is a pic of him with the trophy on the cfc website.
Yeah it wasn’t shared unfortuantely (from a liverpool fan’s pov) Reina is obviously a much better keeper, keeping clean sheets for a worse defence.
But also keeping clean sheets in a much more negative, defensive side. Not that he’s not a class keeper, but Cech or van der Sar would keep just as many clean sheets in such a team.
van der Sar would likely have won the Golden Gloves award had he been fit all season, as Man United kept the most clean sheets in the Premiership. The bottom line is that clean sheets are a moronic way of judging goalkeepers.
Reina’s a great keeper but I wouldn’t have him as the best in Europe this season. Liverpool’s defense isn’t anywhere near as bad as Spurs, for example, yet Gomes propelled his side into the top 4 whereas Liverpool struggled to what, 7th?
Reina’s consistently left out of the awards because he’s consistently not the best keeper in the Premiership.
Still, Reina was probably the better keeper. Liverpool had tonnes of defensive problems and injuries to players in defence. The fact that Liverpool finished 3rd (IIRC) in terms of the best defences in the league is quite astounding considering how far off the pace they are. Liverpool only conceded 3 more than Chelsea (the champions) and a lot of that has to do with Reina.
Would also like to mention me agreement with the author re Reina. Definitely the most underappreciated keeper in Europe/World. Casillas, on the other hand, has to be one of the most overrated. How a player concedes 50+ goals in the league alone and is still considered the best keeper in the world is questionable.
Casillas has had an average, by his standards, season, but it’s important to remember that he plays for a club where he’s basically the entire defense all by himself.
He’s probably been about as good, maybe a little poorer, as Reina, when you adjust for their respective defenses ie. Reina gets to play behind one.
Please, that’s really a poor excuse. I am talking about last season where Iker was so resoundingly called the best keeper in the world. In the same season where Real Madrid conceded 50+ goals, many lesser teams with lesser defences, lesser budgets and lesser help achieved much better. There is absolutely no excuse for conceding that many goals. Poor defence? Come on.
Casillas has been far poorer than Reina, who was, quite rightfully, put as first choice in this side. Casillas suffered the worst season of his career imo, looked shaky and clearly lost some confidence, Real’s defence seemingly feeling that way also. Reina should be ahead of Casillas in the Spanish pecking order on form, as should Valdes.
Reina has been consistently excellent since joining Liverpool, his the most comfortable keeper I’ve ever seen with the ball at his feet, is the best distributor around in that position, commands his goal excellently, reads play brilliantly and removes chances befoere they are even present, which is just as important as the eye catching saves the likes of Cech, Casillas and Given make, that Reina does just as well. A sweeper-keeper indeed.
And all this guff about Liverpool being better than Spurs defensively, or more defensive than other teams, is quite frankly, bull. Liverpool’s suspect defence has been evident throughout the season, the inadequate Insua at left back, Carragher suffering his worst season in a red shirt and being poor for the majority of it, Skrtel nearly completely blowing his reputation, and being consigned below Kyrgiakos in the pecking order. In fact with two out and out attacking full backs starting, it’s quite clear that Liverpool aren’t the most defensively astute, or defensively mided team. Liverpool have been poorer going forward due to a huge lack of creativity with Aquilani hardly being used and complete lack of cutting edge minus Fernando Torres and with the likes of Gerrard and Kuyt off form. That Reina has performed to the standard he has done, and kept that many clean sheets for a team with a consistently changing back line, devoid of confidence, underperforming, and with players who may not be good enough, as well as finishing 7th, exhibits the man’s undeniable quality. The best keeper in the premiership by some way, and one of the top 3 in world football currently.
I would take issue with Rooney’s inclusion over Drogba’s. The Ivorian has more goals, assists and has scored his goals more evenly against better quality opposition. Rooney has been tremendous, but Didier slightly more so imo.
You can never please everyone with such inventions. The full-backs are clearly there to create a bit of discussion
You could argue that Riise cost Roma the title against Samp if you wanted to be particularly harsh. The move to Roma has re-invigorated him somewhat!
I had never really seen or noticed Pizarro. I will definitely be looking out for him in the future, looks like a quality Regista.
Yep, for me Maicon is easily better than Alves.
Surprised to see Riise in there, but haven’t seen much Italian football outside the CL this season, so can’t complain!
I would agree that Maicon is better technical player than Alves, I think his passing, crossing and shooting are better. Given the choice though, I’d have Alves every time! I don’t think I’ve ever seen a player cover so much ground, it’s like having an extra man on the right hand side and creates so much space for Messi and Xavi in particular.
Agree with the others that Maicon has to be in over Alves. Also have to go with Ronaldo over Robben – Robben’s been good but Ronaldo’s been as brilliant as Messi this season when you account for the lesser number of games played (plus if you’re actually trying to put together a team, Messi and Robben play the same position). And also definitely have to go with Cole or Evra over Risse Think your Barca/Roma fandom might have influenced a few of these choices.
Otherwise, spot on. Goalkeeper’s a toss up in many ways, personally I’d stump for Julio Cesar, but Reina’s a good choice, although he might not have as many clean sheets if Liverpool didn’t play such negative football.
Messi and Robben don’t really play the same position, at least not all the time. Robben is strictly a winger and he starts from near the touchline almost all the time. Messi has played pretty much every attacking position this year; he has been the striker in a front 3, behind the striker in Barca’s main European 4-2-4 / 4-2-3-1 unique shape, and a right winger who is more of a striker who just happens to be wide in their 4-3-3.
To say that Ronaldo has been “as brilliant as Messi” is just strange. Ronaldo has been brilliant, but Messi this season has been as good as any player in any year. He has matched Ronaldo (Brazilian)’s amazing season in terms of goals, and without always being the main striker and contributing so much more than goals.
I think Jonathan is talking about Ronaldo’s output and it’s hard to disagree. He has been imperious, but the sheer numbers Messi has put up because he played more games casts a shadow over him. I agree that Ronaldo has probably been better than Robben, but Robben has played a huge role in Bayern’s success so his inclusion isn’t without it’s merits.
don’t think you can compare ronaldo’s season with messi’s despite the ratios being similar. ronaldo may have scored a lot of goals this year but he was a frustrating figure in some of real’s most important matches (eg lyon both legs, despite scoring once – el clasico twice). messi on the other hand did pretty well in both el clasicos, scored 4 against arsenal, the hattrick against valencia who are of course the third placed side. the best players achieve as well as perform. obviously not saying ronaldo isn’t close to messi because of course, he is, but messi’s season is unparalleled imo. only black mark being inter nullifying him by superbly triple marking him (not meaning this sarcastically)
Messi scores more goals from a deeper position. A lot of CR’s are pk’s, Messi had zero pk’s in La Liga and still scored 34. Messi is far more involved in the buildup, sometimes he even plays as a midfielder. Messi is a big part of Barca’s pressing game. Amazingly, he often leads the teams in tackles.
Pretty much spot on, can’t argue with much. Although I would include Lahm, in the reserve team at least. He switched to RB and has contributed to more goals than ever before in his career and was a big reason Robben and Bayern did so well. Schweinsteiger and Mark van Bommel also deserve praise this year.
I can’t understand why you chose Rooney over Drogba.
Considering the fact that Drogba scored more goals, despite taking only one penalty this season (Rooney scored 5, not sure if that’s the same number as he took) and spending a month at The African Cup of Nations, he is undoubtedly the best striker in England.
Rooney is a great player, but over-rated in my opinion. English fans were touting him as “the best player in the world” before Messi demolished Arsenal and made that arguement impossible to sustain. Rooney has, for the first time in his career, had an extremely prolific season inforont of goal. But he’s not doing anything that Henry, Eto’o, Drogba, Torres, Forlan and Toni haven’t done in the last few years.
Don’t get me wrong, Rooney is one of the top strikers in Europe, no doubt about it, but that’s all he is; a top-notch striker, special, but not astonishing.
Not that I’m accusing you of exaggerating Rooney’s ability ZM, just sayin’ generally…
It did occur to me that you may have deliberately gone for 3 smaller, more mobile strikers in order to suit Messi, I know you didn’t like the way Ibra stiffled him against Arsenal, something that, one can only assume, Drogba would similarly be guilty of.
Which begs the question; is your team actaully chosen as a team, or is it a list of the individual players that you feel have been the best in their respective positions?
Anyway, big fan of the site, keep up the good work.
Patrick
nice post. finally, someone with something to say other than “why haven’t you chosen the most obvious”…
ps ZM = je t’ aime ???
He told you why he picked Rooney – the trend for European strikers to be versatile and be able to play a variety of roles.
Drogba’s probably a better pure striker, and he certainly plays for a much, much more attack minded team, but Rooney’s versatility and form in various roles this season make him better as a modern forward – someone who can play anywhere.
Chile have qualified for the WC.. David Pizarro is not selected? That is unbelievable.. previously, I felt Cambiasso’s exclusion was the worst decision but this just takes the cake.
Oh, and great job with the website, ZM. Your fans here in Malaysia are delighted you’re gonna be analysing the WC matches too. Congrats n all the best.
Sadly Pizarro has retired from international football because of problems with the management / other players. AWful shame.
In 2005 he retired from the national squad because he thought that most of the squad members were completely undisciplined and not committed with the qualifyings process. In deed it has been a really great loss for Chile. Actionally, even the president of the Republic interceded 3 years ago to convince him to return to the squad, but he kept with his decision.
However, it’s difficult to define in which possition he may play on Bielsa’s team. On a 3-3-1-3, the defensive midfielder is completely committed on defensive role and has to be very fast and well poscitioned to fullfill the spaces that the wing backs leaves whent they go into attack (there usually plays Carlos Carmona from Reggina or Mauricio Isla from Udinese). In the other hand, the trequartista is a player that often catches the ball in the midfield or below and commands the counter-strike, so there is needed a fast player, and David is not as fast as Matías Fernández or Jorge Valdivia. However, Bielsa plays sometimes with a 4-3-3, with one defensive midfielder, one central midfielder and one trequartista, so in that formation David may fit.
Maybe you can write a tactical analysis of chilean squad, it could be very interesting.
Regards, and congrats to ZM for their awsome tactical analysis.
I hate to pile on, but Maicon > Alves. Dunga, head to head domination and a few intentionally awesome goals are nothing to sneeze at. I’d also take Drogba over Rooney this year, even if the latter is a little more versatile. The head to head stats and team success suggest that Drogba is a victim of his reputation and Rooney’s Englishness. Great list though.
Gotta have Drogba over Rooney. I know he’s a pain in the neck and really
an asshole of a teammate, but Drogba was really golden this season. The
last two years he even added the free kicks to his arsenal. Also, the fact that
he’s making Anelka look good again has to count for something.
Great team, great to read about some players like Pizzaro, Riise and Robben who I haven’t seen an awful lot of this season but obviously had stellar campaigns.
On another note, I just want to congratulate you on a truly terrific website ZM. I only discovered it over the last couple of months and believe it’s right up there with the very best football websites in the world. You write with conviction and you always back yourself up, which is exactly what creates a comments section that is void of people cutting into your work.
Well done on a terrific season and I can’t wait to read about World Cup tactics!
Many thanks.
I’ll 2nd what Andrew said – fantastic site!
Absolutely. Great stuff. You nailed the analysis of Barca-Inter, noting salient points that other writers didn’t catch, particularly Pep’s unwillingness/failure to adjust and put Ibra in a position to succeed. I forwarded that article to a bunch of friends that were frustrated in Ibra.
hm, … the list might have to be rewritten after the CL final…lol…. e.g. Lucio is a good player, but over a season not total reliable and doesn’t stick always to the coach’s proposed order … which is likely the reason LvG wasn’t unhappy to give him away…
Schweinsteiger had a terrific development this season and might crown it in the final and one very important reason for Robben’s performance is the fact that he has a Philipp Lahm behind him that makes it very difficult for teams to double him when he cuts in…
…I assume the last aspect could be said about a lot of other players: they only shine with the right (often underestimated) partners – might be one of the reasons why the seasons for RM end so often without titles despite the money they spent for stars…
Great choices !
Haven’t watched too much Serie A so cant argue with the choices from there. Pizarro seems a very intelligent player although a bit slow while moving with the ball.
The decription of Lucio was brilliant.
Good list. Cant argue much as it’s ZM’s choice and most of the choices are convincing. But how can you ignore Ronaldo? Given the circumstances, he was the best Madrid player. I havent seen him play with so much passion as he displayed since returning from injury. He is being harshly judged as all the spotlight seems to be on Messi. But that is hardly Ronaldo’s fault. I will have him in my team anyday and would surely prefer him over Robben, atlleast with what he brings on the table. Also, Drogbma should have been named instead of Rooney. I know the English press is going ga-ga over Rooney and he is great too but believe me Drogba possesses all the same same qualities and much more.
He’s been great, but I don’t think he can be in there ahead of Robben. Ronaldo didn’t really play particularly well in the few big games he played in this season. Not a criticism, but compared to Robben who scored so many crucial goals…
In fairness on pure performance he has certainly played well enough to be in a European XI, but then you realise that there have been some brilliant attacking performances this season, and if Ronaldo was included then one of the front three would have to be left out…
I would partly agree to it. Ronaldo didnt score many crucial goals this season and Robben has done exactly that. When you are a 80 milion player worth player there are bound to be huge expectations. But in all honesty, he has justified his multi-million dollar signing. And he alone cannot carry Madrid everytime. They need other 10 players to kick some balls too.
P.S.-Villa has signed for Barcelona and Fabregas is pressing Arsenal for a move.
Wonder where will that take Barca.
i totally agree with you Don…Drogba possesses all the same qualities and much more than rooney.His free kicks are always a threat & he is third on the list of top assists,4 behind lampard & 2 behind fabregas…rooney is nowhere near Drogba on this list.
If a player has won the golden boot award(29 goals) inspite of missing games because of ACN and also is third on the list of most assists, surely the guy has done something right this season. He’s got just one penalty as compared to Rooney’s five. Not that Rooney is not good, just that Drogba’s been better and deserves a chance to be in the team of the season. And his performance against the other top three has been fantastic. A noticeable ommision.
Good Article. Great Website. The videos are a nice touch.
rooney should never be there it should be drogba instead and there has to be ronaldo in there as well in place of whom i’m not sure
That’s the problem!
Big Roma fan, but wouldn’t choose Rouse. Big help for the team, but not the best. Like mentioned above-the samp game (among others). He was the weak side defensively often. Forgivable in the context of the team, but not in a dream side. Pizzaro is dead on.
Can image a dream b team that would give this one a run for its money.
Imo,the centre forward should be Milito.He might not have scored as many goals as Rooney and Drogba.But he’s scored much more important ones.But being realistic,isn’t a pizzro xavi Midfield too lightweight.Maybe for bigger games,one will have to sit on the bench!
My understanding is that ZM is trying to recreate the fluid 4231 that many top teams play and has chosen the best players for that formation. That is why Rooney is preferable to Drogba (Rooney, like Messi, can pay any of the 4 attacking positions in this formation). He is not the best striker in Europe but if you are playing this style then there has been one better this season.
That is how I understood it anyway. Both Pizarro and Xavi need a more defensive player next to them so I think the midfield is a bit light weight.
Why does everyone keep stating that Maicon is better than Alves? Ofcourse overall he is the better player. That’s why he’s in the first XI of Brazil and Alves is on the bench.
Never really paid much attention to Pizzaro. Thanks for highlighting his talent.One to look forward to.
Good work ZM…big fan of the site.
I agree that Maicon is better than Alves overall, but this season he hasn’t been as consistent as the previous ones at Inter, I believe Daniel Alves had a better season.
Lucio – Mourinho actually asked for Carvalho. In Italy the manager doesn’t have a role that involves the transfer market (as it is in the UK), it’s Branca and Oriali who deserve Inter fans’ gratitude for signing Lucio (and selling Ibra for 50m + Eto’o, signing Milito and Thiago Motta, Snejder, Pandev this season only, but if you check the previous seasons you will se many other brilliant signings). Mourinho definitely had a role in asking a ball-playing defender and creative midfielders like Snejider and Motta.
Hm, a great topic for debate, and I agree with most of the players in the best 11 (as well as the reserve 11). I’m going to add a few more players, all from the Premier League, who I think are worthy of inclusion in this list:
Joe Hart – GK (Terrific season in a top league in Europe)
Gareth Bale – RB (Only recently shown his form but proved he can handle the big games)
Patrice Evra – LB (Experienced, and rarely has a poor run of games)
Roger Johnson – CB (First full season in Premier League but proved he belongs there)
Scott Dann – CB (See Roger Johnson)
Adam Johnson – RM (Similar to Gareth Bale, terrific ability)
James Milner – CM (Versatile, and packs a mean shot)
Paul Scholes – CM (Many players will wish they can play as well as him when they’re older!)
Florent Malouda – LM (Excellent season where he’s shown his true worth)
Carlos Tevez – CF (Got the goals to go with his high level of performance)
Fernando Torres – ST (If not for injuries, Liverpool would be higher up the table…)
Gareth Bale at RB? Has he ever played anywhere other than on the left touchline?
Very true and furthermore may I speculate that he only really hit good form in the final 5-10 or so fixtures?
For anyone who is interested, an objective Team of the Season from the Bundesliga.
———————-Mueller————————-
Lahm——–Hyypia—–Hummels———–Castro
————-MvB———Schweinsteiger————
—-Robben——-Kroos/Oezil———–Marin———–
——————-Dzeko——————————
Subs: Butt, Bordon, Frings, Missimovic, Kroos/Oezil, Mueller, Kiessling, Kuranyi, Barrios
Where’s Ribery???
probably in a brothel lol
haha, excellent.
Ribery has, in all seriousness, been poor by his standards this season.
Bayern have relied vastly more on Robben – Ribery’s reputation is much higher than his performances at the moment.
He missed large parts of the season due to injury and was never able to play consistently or rediscover his full form.
..he is nearly back and still much better than Marin …and demonstrated it in the Cup final in Berlin … Kuranyi is a very limited player and comes behind Gomez and Klose anyway…Hummels has talent, but so has Badstuber and a few others, there are definitely better players on this postion in the Bundesliga… I only agree with Lahm, Kroos, Oezil, Robben, Schweinsteiger and Dzeko
cerser
alves
lusio
picure
cole
lampard
xavi
maulda
messi
drobga
rondaldo
@ Zonal Marking.
What are your reasons behind choosing Riise and Cole ahead of Evra? Not having a go, just curious.
I would have gone for Drogba ahead of Rooney because he scored more created more and deadly with his freekicks this season. so if you look at the statistics its definitely Drogba >> Rooney. And though i donno much about Riise, A.Cole scored some 4-5 goals this season including the one in the final game. How can you underestimate such a contribution from someone who didn’t play for 3 months. Also his overlapping has been amazing this season and acc to me the best overlapping LeftBack in the world now even over Evra…
I have to disagree with you on both Rooney vs. Drogba and Evra vs. Cole. Rooney is a better all-round footballer, he brings much more to the team. And regarding Evra, he’s a better defender as well as being one of Man united’s best attacking outlets, and never has a bad game, where on occasion, Cole does.
I think Cole’s probably a marginally better overall player than Evra, but considering his injury, I can’t see how you can justify picking Cole in a team of the season.
A question to the author, who was in your first XI last year?
I second this excellent question, ZM, though of course if you didn’t write it down I imagine it’ll be hard to decide one now that you’ve seen this seasonn.
I would put in a word for Ledley King of Tottenham Hotspur.
A fit Ledley King is the best central defender that I have seen in my entire life.
Watch out for him in the World Cup and check back on this list after you see him.
Simply awesome.
I agree; however, this person, “a fit Ledley King” simply does not exist. It’s pretty hard to select someone who can’t get into 20 games a season. Spectacular when he’s there, though. Characteristically, his World Cup was great — and 45 minutes long.
Maicon should be ahead of Alves – I’ve seen nearly all Barcelona games and more than half of Inter’s games and there’s no way I could justify picking Alves over Maicon. Same with Pizarro, who is hardly underrated in my opinion and does not deserve to be included here .
On the other hand, picking Rooney over Drogba should hardly be a debate at all. Riise’s a nice inclusion too.
Cech won the golden gloves, he had as much clean sheets, but played a lot less games. The one with the best ratio always gets it.
Pizarro is fantastic, very underrated. Riise, just no.
This is excellent. Especially because you chose Alves over Maicon.
But I am not sure how Ronaldo missed it or who should be dropped for Ronaldo – May be Ronaldo in the first half and Robben in the second. Since Messi can manage anywhere he will adapt accordingly to this change.
I always dream watching Messi and Ronaldo playing together. What an attack it could be with Iniesta and Xavi to back them.
Pizzaro I’m very glad to see in there I don’t much Italian football sadly no espn, but saw him against arsenal in the champs last year and he came off the bench and really stood out in a dour game, has a xavi esk ability in retaining the ball under pressure. Sneijder has been brillient this year surely the most technically proficent advanced cm player in the world, what do think about him following mourinho back to Madrid? Would obviously like everyone else like my own players in the team, but a thorough selection that has highlighted lesser known players, glad to see you mentioned Cesc; who in my mind has been the best player in the prem this year, and without injury would have cruised into this team. Would be nice if you could do a team for all the top leagues; England, Italy, Spain, Germany, France etc.
One of the tough things about doing something like this is distinguishing between the best players and the players who have performed the best. To me that is why Cole misses out to Riise, why Ronaldo isn’t in the team etc. I guess it’s the difference between recognising achievement and actual performance (which this list does) or figuring out who you would pick as the best XI if Earth had to play Mars.
This is what so many people didn’t get, and why everyone is like: “but the list should have Drogba/Cole/Ronaldo/Cech/Maicon/Milito/Lahm/all the players from my favorite team” instead of considering their actual performance.
I second the requests for team from each league, placed in suitable formations though. We would have some nice variety.
Consensus so far from posters seems to support the consideration of Evra & Lahm, though Maicon, Alves, Cole, Felipe and I guess Riise keep them out.
Ooh, and you’ve got a nice edit facility on here now ZM. Thanks
I third that request.
It would be more interesting for both the main and the reserve to have a coach (although I think we all know those two)
Interesting that someone has produced a “team of the year” that kind of reflects European football this season. Good stuff.
Drogba has been the best forward in England (again) despite all the positive press that Rooney has received. If there is one thing that needs to be addressed in English analysis of football it is the determination of the press to champion British players ahead of others. In consequence there is a trend that seems to dismiss much of this media glorification to an extreme level where players like Lampard are vilified for not being as good as skysports and bbc keep on telling us they are.
Lampard is not in the same quality as Xavi, Pirlo, Ballack etc, yet still provides a pivotal function for Chelsea in an attacking outlet. I would suggest he is not of the same quality of the midfielders included but the importance of his function is second only to Xavi.
ZM, is the world cup preview on England going to focus on whether Lampard should start in a 4 man midfield, using the England-Egypt friendly as a argument both for and against?
A good list, but I would have included Lampard (in place of Sneider / Pizarro) Ronaldo (in place of Robben) and Drogba (in place of Rooney).
“If there is one thing that needs to be addressed in English analysis of football it is the determination of the press to champion British players ahead of others.”
Truth.
I agree
A few things I disagree with:
Cech won the Golden Gloves, not Reina. They got the same number of clean sheets, but Cech managed it in fewer games.
Maicon was better than Alves this season. Not to take anything away from Alves, who was excellent, but I feel that Maicon was the better player.
Riise was good, but Ashley Cole was phenomenal this season. Had he been fit for the whole season, he would have been Chelsea’s best player.
No real problems with the midfield, although I question whether a midfield with both Xavi and Pizarro in would work.
No Drogba? He got more goals and more assists than Rooney, and was the better player (again). He was struggling with injury towards the end of the season and still put in a selection of heroic performances.
Interesting that you chose not to include a single Chelsea player…
The all–conventional-wisdom squad, for everyone who loves stars, follows the EPL and CL, and can’t accept the presence of unsung players (in classic english 442 of course):
Cech
Cole
Pique
Lucio
Maicon
Ronaldo
Lampard
Fabregas
Messi
Drogba
Rooney
and wait, let me squeeze in a paraphrased condensation of the vast majority of comments:
Drogba was better than Rooney
Evra was better than Riise
Cole was better than Riise
Maicon was better than Alves
Ronaldo was better than… somebody. let’s drop a central midfielder!
Absolutely Pathetic squad. And it’s foolishness to only follow EPL. Next Up, I will be giving my own list of the best 11 playing in the Dutch League.
So you decide to drop Xavi.. well done..
Quick question on Messi:
Why is everyone drooling over his two hat-tricks when I thought the better compilation is his 4 against Arsenal? How many times has anyone seen a player beat a keeper over, under, left and right all in one game?
I don’t think there’s every been a more quality super-hattrick. Even the “easy” 2nd goal required great awareness, quickness, and a perfect first touch.
I am very surprised by the exclusion of a defensive minded midfielder as well as Maicon.The rest is almost there
I would love to see in this list also Eto’o.He did a majestic job this season.He scored considerably less goals this year but they were always decisives (he brought as many point as Milito in serie A scoring just a little more than half of him), and whenever he was used as a striker in place of Milito and not as a winger he ALWAYS put at least one goal in the net.With the change from 4-3-1-2 to 4-2-3-1 and his consequent change of role he obviously began to score less but he did a magnificent job,always doing what mourinho asked,putting the sake of the team on top of everything else.I saw him running 80 meters back to defend in the two games Of Inter and Barcelona when everyone else in his team was so tired they couldn’t even properly control the ball (the last 20 minutes of the first leg come to my mind).He came with a reputation of someone that causes some troubles in the locker room but he NEVER complained even if he was used not in his proper role or when mourinho put him on the bench for a while after the CAF.And on top of all that,he can become the first player in the world to achieve a treble twice (and in two consequent years),and that has to mean something no?:)
Ps:love your site,i’m italian and in my country they never do proper tactical analysis(always blabbling only about the referee or about controverseries between coaches,players,managers…),this is really fresh and new to me
Eto’o did a respectable job at Inter. He provided plenty of threat down the flank and linked up well with Milito and Sneijder, even willing to defend deep in Inter’s own half. That said, it’s hard to place him in front of Messi, Rooney, Robben, Ronaldo, and Drogba, all of whom have been absolutely fantastic and irreplaceable for their own clubs.
What!? No Fulham Players?!
Zamora has been a revelation in Europe this season – giving many ‘top’ CB’s a absolute torrid time!
I think this squad is simply magic and ZM knew he would never please everyone. Me, myself, would change some players as bellow:
GK – Julio Cesar
Not only because I’m a Brazilian but I think you’re talking about Reina and Cech because you all watch too much Premier League games. Once you get a closer eye on all main teams full season you’ll start to notice keepers like Julio Cesar and Lloris.
RB – Maicon
I agree the question here is between Maicon and Dani Alves but a lot of other players are over Ivanovic. People talk about Ivanovic because he was a very good surprise on the RB. He’s perfoming so much better than what we thought he would have that we already jump to think he is the 2nd best RB on earth.
LB – J. Zanetti
ZM, who understands best what his coach says better than Zanetti? It is not as easy as it looks, plus he is the major leader of the best team of the season. He plays on both flanks and also in the middle if needed. Don’t be Maradonas and dare to leave him out of any list.
CB – Lucio
I couldn’t agree more with ZM. Some friends of mine away from Brazil say he is too violent and mean. I’d say a forward has to be very brave and skillfull to pass by Lucio – I think Didier agrees with me on this. That was the greatest individual performance a CB ever had in such an important game. Great leader also.
CB – Pique
I’m not a huge fan of Pique but ZM got me there. How many forwards could score a goal like that? When Barça needs a goal, the first thing Guardiola does is too put Pique up front. I don’t se Samuel that well and I like Roma’s defense with Burdisso, Mexes and Juan.
DMF – Cambiasso
What a great season this very talented and rough player has done at Inter Milan. It’s very hard to pass by him and he can switch the ball from one side to the other as it were the easiest thing.
CMF – Xavi
Does anyone would like to have an argue about this one?? I didn’t think so.
AMF – Sneijder
Real Madrid’s garbage is now one of the main players of the game and rarelly hides from a game, like most of AMFs. Probably the best player of the best team of the season.
RFW – Messi
Does anyone would like to have an argue about him too?
LFW – Robben
Another garbage from Real Madrid. True that C. Ronaldo is a much more talented player and had a great season, but you just can’t forget the very very crucial goals he has scored this season for both Champions League and Bundesleague
CF – Rooney
The argue between Drogba and Rooney has its point but after Messi and Xavi(perhaps), no one is a better soccer player than Rooney. Even though Drogba is one of the best too. You can’t forget Higuaín too. He is not the best player ever but you’ll agree his season was simply magestic.
The best XI of Brazil’s first half of the season. The regular brazilian style 4-2-2-2.
GK – Victor(Grêmio)
You won’t find a person in Brazil who would rather have Doni instead of Victor on the seleção.
RB – Nei(internacional)
Pará(Santos) was also great.
LB – Roberto Carlos(Corinthians)
Yes, Roberto Carlos!
CB – Alex Silva(São Paulo)
Very tall and skillfull defender.
CB – Chicão(Corinthians)
Great on set pieces too.
DMF – Elias(Corinthians)
Comming from behing he is great. Great marking skills too.
DMF – Wesley(Santos)
Great first semester too! Scored very important goals comming from behind.
AMF – D’alessandro(Internacional)
He is Argentinian but is the key player of Jorge Fossati’s Internacional.
AMF – Paulo Henrique Ganso(Santos)
Great player. He is 20 and he will surelly be the best player on eath. His talent scares people in Brazil right now. Too bad Dunga only called him to be in the 30 best.
CF – Neymar(Santos)
Ver very very skillfull player. His style looks like Robinho’s but he is even more incisive. Wacth him scoring a PK too agree with me.
CF – Thiago Ribeiro(Cruzeiro)
Very very fast he is scoring very important goals at Libertadores.
Goal keeper is more of a personal choice. As there is no stand out keeper this year. And a lot have been very consistent over the season. Buffon, Cassilas, VDS, Cech, Reina and Lloris to name a few.
Defenders- Pretty surprise that no one question the inclusion of Pique in the team. For all his calmness on the ball and reading of the game, he is no where near Nesta or even Ferdinand. Both of them started the season well until injuries take his toll. But for this dream team, I would choose the partnership of Lucio and Samuel. They have already shut down the entire Seria A, the best of EPL (Chelsea) and the Spanish League (Barca). So why break up that perfect tandem.
And then the full-backs. I’m with most posters here. Evra and Maicon should be included over Risse and Alves. As with Risse, Evra is the one that is expected to defend and to provide attacking treat on the left, especially when couple with Nani who loves to cut inside.
What ever Alves did, Maicon did it as well. And the reason why I choose Maicon is that he is better on the defensive end. Pacey on the ground, solid in the air.
Midfielders- Agreed on the Xavi pick. Xavi is by far the best mover of the ball in the world now. Pizzaro have shown his class this season. But I would pick Cambiasso. Same reason as the center backs selection. The axis of Lucia, Samuel and Cambiasso is a proven tandem.
While Sneider have shown a brilliant season. Hamsik is not to shabby either. Carrying Napoli into 6th and Slovakia to the Finals.
Forwards- Messi, Ronaldo and Rooney would be the perfect trio. Robben have a good season but he did not have anything extra on this 3. While Drogba could be the focal point of team, but he do not have the flexibility to move into either wings or dropping back into the hole.
So in the end, I concluded my dream 11 of the season as Lloeis, Evra, Lucio, Samuel, Maicon, Cambiasso, Xavi, Hamsik, Messi, Ronaldo and Rooney.
Alves over Maicon is a mistake. Maicon is a superior player, way better defensively.
But he hasn’t had a better season.
Huh? A is going for the treble while B “only” was able to win the league.
A started every single game ahead of B for their national team.
A have 8 goals and 15 assist while B have 5 goals and 15 assists.
Guess who is A?
I’m sorry ZM, picking a player for your Dream team is your choice. But to say that Alves have a better season compare to Maicon is a bit of a stretch.
It’s nothing to do with the national team
Three goals is little difference really, and don’t think such a narrow result in the Inter v Barca tie should negate the fact that Alves has generally played the better footballer.
i agree on most of your picks, and its nice to see Robben and Sneijder, who both had a great season. In holland there is a lot of debate going on about the national team, and to be more specific, the strikers and the attacking midfielders. Van Persie said more than once to the media that he wants to play together with Robben, van der Vaart and Sneijder at the same time. Van Persie would be the striker (his arsenal role):
————–Van Persie—————
v/d Vaart——-Sneijder———Robben
while this is the traditional line up:
————-Huntelaar—————–
Robben———Sneijder———-Kuijt
My question to you is: what is your opinion about the van Persie line up? In the end, this is mostly a question about what Dirk Kuijts contribution could be to the team. IMO, Kuijt is a terrific tactical asset (not a Liverpool fan), and should be included in the starting XI. If things go downhill, he should be subbed for Elia of v/d Vaart. As i’ve read from you before, cramming all your best players in the team just to play together can lead to imbalance.
What do you think?
I think Sneijder and Van Persie hate each other so much that they may just refuse to pass the ball between them.
Doesn’t Robben hate RVP too? Maybe Sneijder and Robben will play monkey in the middle against RVP. Anyway, the Dutch team is sure good to watch.
I agree with most of ZM’s team and I had most of those players on my Serie A, La Liga or Premier League teams of the year.
Haven’t made a Bundesliga team but Robben should be player of the year in Germany so I definitely have no qualms about him.
Instead of putting another team together here is an attempt at a best of top 5 position by position compilation.
Mind you best performances, not best players – for that feel free to take a look at my rather unique (I think so myself anyway) list of the 200 best players in the world here: longthrowins.blogspot com (writeup count 56000 words – sorry for the shameless plug).
GOALKEEPERS:
1. Gomez
2. Reina
3. Lloris (for those not having noticed yet, established himself as one of world’s best this season. A new Casillas?
Somewhat similar situation in Germany with Schalke keeper Neuer but he is still a little wild I think. Will make miracle saves though.
In England Joe Hart was excellent and deserves mention. He should be the England number 1 now imo)
4. Salvatore Sirigu (with Cesar’s form somewhat erratic this season the best in Italy. Doni and Storari started too few games to get selected. Closest in my book at least might be Lazio/Uruguay keeper Muslera)
5. Diego Alves (credit to Valdes for becoming really good but I’ll go with the guy who really had to save his team. Young Atletico keeper De Gea is the up and comer)
CENTRAL DEFENDERS:
1. Walter Samuel (Lucio the more talented player but I’ll go with Samuel as the even better defender. Lucio’s dinosaur slowness I felt did cost Inter at times this season)
2. Pique
3. Simon Kjaer (honorary mentions Juan, Ciani, Hyppia and Nesta)
4. Bordon (Schalke rock)
5. Diawara (Marseille rock)
BACKS (left and right)
1. Alves (yes Maicon is better overall but for the first half of the season he just wasn’t at his best)
2. Ivanovic (just an awesome revelation)
3. Maicon
4. Tremoulinas (yes Bordeaux eventually collapsed but for much of the season Tremoulinas was really good in both ends on what was a very effective team)
5. Zanetti (as usual he was used in midfield too but even in his least favorite position, left-back, where both Chivu and Santon were out he did really well. Honorary mentions: Riise, Arbeloa, Castro and Lahm who I hope to see return to LB soon)
CENTRAL MIDFIELD:
1. Xavi
2. Xabi Alonso
3. David Pizarro
4. Cambiasso
5. Banega (just edges out Schweinsteiger who did great in central midfield this season. Fletcher also deserves a mention)
ATTACKING MIDFIELD:
1. Fabregas
2. Lampard (don’t really agree with the negativity that started appearing in the early part his season. I thought he was great there too. Just not in an ideal position to score goals. He continues to be a scary effective player also because of his defensive work.
3. Modric
4. Sneijder
5. Özil (honorary mentions: Hamsik, Lucho Gonzalez and Gourcuff)
FORWARDS (with wingers)
1. Messi
2. Robben
3. C. Ronaldo
4. Malouda
5. Hazard (guess I’ll put him in this category. Should take the world by storm soon. Honorary mentions: Pedro, Valencia and Jesus Navas)
STRIKERS:
1. Rooney
2. Drogba
3. Milito
4. Higuain
5. Di Natale (it almost has to be seen to be believed how good he was this season. Was very creative too creating chances for others. Just no one but himself to score…)
Brilliant team! I think I would’ve had a few change, but its hard to argue your selections. How about a a U21 team of the season?
Not a single Chelsea player in starting line-up? Atleast Drogba > Rooney. But then Rooney also has been fantastic this season.
And where is Fletcher?
Where is Landon Donovan?
Surely there is a mistake; David N’gog is missing from the list.
That Reina video is not proper..
The second clip where he sends in that long ball to score against Villa was in the 2008-2009 season and not the 2009-2010 season
Hence why it says “from 2009″
If you can find a video of him from 2009/10, feel free to post it.
Who would be the manager of this team?????
Whose the manager of the season????
..the one who wins the final
Jose Mourinho
)
1) Guardiola
2) Mourinho
No offense ZM, for the first time I BIG disagree with your choice.
Maicon deserves the Alves place, yeah his performance downed a bit around Christmas+New Year but after that he jump-started and now he has better play & stats and more balanced than Alves.
Drogba > Rooney, his goals and assist are way better.
I don’t know why you choose Riise (well I almost think you are Roma fan). His defensive skill, focus, and position is questionable. Even Vargas is better than him in attacking and defense department.
vargas may be better but he hasn’t been anywhere near consistent enough, was benched allot in the second half of the season.
Is three out of eleven “BIG disagreeing”?
Vargas has not only unquestionably had an extremely patchy season, he’s also spent the entire campaign playing at left-wing rather than left-back, so frankly he has no place to replace Riise.
3/11 is still BIG for me because before this article I really “click” with all of your writing.
Can’t wait for your next article for post-match CL final.
N’Gog? You got to be kidding me…
N’Gog is a terrific player. He is better than Drogba
Great line-up.
I honestly believe if Fabregas wasn’t injured this season, he would be ahead of Xavi. His best season at Arsenal with crazy stats of something like 19 goals and 19 assists in 37 games.
I really thought that this website was based on reason and not emotion. I was clearly mistaken. To take so many Barcelona players and to leave out some of the pure class in Madrid players kind of tips your hand. And to leave out Ronaldo who is probably the best player in the world if not the 2nd is a joke. You can call it “an opinion” if you wish, but it is obvious that you are a Barcalona fan from your previous writings, and this one obviously takes the cake.
Cech actually won the Golden Gloves rather than Reina for having a better cleansheet-games played ratio.
David Pizarro and Sneijder ahead of Cesc Fabregas for best midfielder? Oh dear, the low-quality analysis is bad enough as it is, but this is just awful. You’ve lost a fan, ZM. Utter lunacy. I don’t even support Arsenal.
I suggest scrapping this article, this website isn’t based on logic, rather on emotion and aesthetics.
If you think it’s low-quality, why were you a fan in the first place?
Thanks for giving us a laugh, though – a quick google of your email address comes up with a page detailing that actually, you are an Arsenal fan (it was bizarre that you decided to put that forward in the first place, making it obvious you were a Gooner).
Sorry to have lost you…
Maicon in general is a better player than Alves but the latter has had a better season unquestionably. On the defending side, I’d say both are competent defenders, Maicon’s physique gives him the edge (let’s not pretend either are fantastic defenders, the CL 1st leg semi saw both make awful errors to cost their side goals). Goals-wise, Maicon has the edge, those powerful diagonal runs of his are hard to stop, and he has a calmness in front of goal that most strikers would be proud of.
But the crucial difference, something that I feel has been evident this season, is that Alves links better with the attack. He’s not just a guy who provides width, he’s got the creative threat of a winger (contrary to what ignorant English pundits tell you, he’s an excellent crosser of the ball) and links up very well with quick movements and passes (according to OPTA he supplied 14 assists and created the 2nd most goalscoring chances after Xavi). He’s a fantastic player and one of the major reasons why Barcelona experienced such an upturn in fortunes in the summer of 08. Not only is he a great player in his own right, his presence in the team has also brought the best out of Messi.
By the way Zonal, did you purposefully miss out Chelsea players for a certain reason or was it something at the end that surprised you? 140 goals+ in all competitions this season, and a domestic double yet you fail to give credit to that in your European XI.
Obviously it was an excellent squad effort, as all things are in football but individuals such as the ever consistent Ivanovic, Lampard who finished with 22 league goals, 17 league assists (More than Xavi in La Liga) and is among the top five most accurate passers in the PL, the best striker in the league Didier Drogba and Florent Malouda who has been a sensation this season.
Chelsea have been underpresented in many XI’s this season.
Not at all. Some were close, four players in the reserve XI. But Bayern and Inter also did doubles (and one will win the treble), Barcelona were incredible and Roma were the best team in Europe since Christmas, so competition was tough.
I mean Malouda, he’s been excellent, but up against Messi, Sneijder and Robben? No chance.
Duly noted, and they’ve all had recognition in your European XI team – Chelsea players have not been, but as I’ve said it’s hardly a surprise as they’ve been under appreciated in many other XI’s too.
A similar statement could be made about David Pizzaro… up against Lampard though? No chance.
David Pizarro has had a far better season than Frank Lampard. Lampard’s been good but mainly in the final third of the season which is fresh in people’s minds. Pizarro has been immense all season. Cole and Drogba would be Chelsea’s closest players here, Fabregas would be ahead of Lampard in the pecking order.
But as I say, it’s always going to be impossible to please everyone, people will always feel that ‘their team’ has been unrepresented.
The same criticism could be applied to Malouda, but it’s a pretty harsh one to apply to Frank Lampard. I’d extend that and say his ‘world class’ run of form has come in the final two thirds and for the majority of the season. Previously, he was playing in an unfavoured diamond formation that didn’t allow him to score as many goals with the attacking emphasis more on the player in the hole (Deco or Joe Cole), Drogba and Anelka – but despite not scoring as freely, it doesn’t mean Frank Lampard wasn’t fulfilling his role effectively. Lampard was still able to maintain shape and structure within the diamond, and his (and Ballack’s) industrious performances ensured our midfield was never over run and thus never dominated throughout our experimental period with the diamond, and that was every bit key to its partial success as our wing backs and strike force.
Well, it’s clear Didier Drogba has had a better season than Wayne Rooney – it’s just a shame the headlines don’t pick up on that, which seem to inform most nowadays. No surprise that next in your pecking list is Ashley Cole as Riise’s up there instead, despite not showing enough defensively for Roma to be considered in my opinion. I’d rather have Evra there, a consistent 8/10 performer for Manchester United. Attention is always going to lean towards Maicon and Daniel Alves at right back, but Chelsea’s most consistent performer, and probably second best after Drogba deserves a spot in this team after an excellent season out of position.
Of course, but when a team has won a traditional domestic double in arguably the best league in Europe, you would expect some representation.
Ivanovic has been very good but no-one other than Chelsea fans would place him in the best European XI of the season. He’s been excellent defensively, but at times Chelsea have missed having a natural full-back there to provide a genuine attacking threat. Again, a place as a back-up player is fair.
Has Drogba ‘clearly’ had a better season than Rooney, actually. We seem to have reached a stage where people are so keen to protest about perceived bias towards English players, that their achievements are recognized sufficiently when they actually play well. Take a quote from Grant Wahl’s excellent piece about the Brazilian national team this week: “For the first time since 1990 Brazil enters a World Cup without a player considered among the top three in the world—a trio that comprises Argentina’s Lionel Messi, Portugal’s Cristiano Ronaldo and England’s Wayne Rooney”. Whether that’s true is debatable, but the point about ‘headlines seeming to inform’ ignores the worldwide acclaim Rooney has rightly received for his performances this season.
Arguably the best league in Europe? Not this season. The standard of the top 4 has been very weak, the weakest it has been for years, summed up by the English clubs’ poor performance in the Champions League. Chelsea winning it doesn’t entitle them to places in a European XI, it’s merely about who the best players have been. No Chelsea player has been the best in his position in Europe this season, with the arguable exception of Cole, who was out injured when Chelsea were playing their best football anyway, making him difficult to include.
Well that’s likely to be true, but had he started the season with a similar reputation to Dani Alves and Maicon that statement may not be entirely correct. It’s always harder to impress further afield when you start the season as a back up player – as it usually goes from supporters making noise about a certain player, to that being picked up on a national level and then internationally and possibly Ivanovic has failed to reach that third spot, possibly because of our earlier than usual exit in the Champions League. It’s a similar sitaution with Gareth Bale, Tottenham supporters were making noise about him from January, yet it was only when Spurs had a few televised matches in a row he was recognised on a more national level as being a fantastic talent.
Ivanovic does have a slightly unconventional attacking style down the right hand side, which is arguably clumsy but is effective and he does deliver an excellent cross – but we’ve missed Bosingwa for his absolute dominance and control of the right hand side. It doesn’t surprise me Ivanovic doesn’t reach European XI’s of the season yet, however if he reproduces this form once again next season (although it’s more likely to be at CB) he may get more recognition from further afield.
Many of the English players in the Premier League are over rated because of the hype built up around them. At times, that’s been the case with Wayne Rooney, and that’s why many perceive he’s had a better season than Didier Drogba. Ignoring the fact he has less assists and less league goals and struggled for quite a while scoring against sides in the top half of the table, yet scoring freely against struggling Portsmouth et al which boosted his goal tally.
The league extends further than the top few positions. Tottenham have improved by 19 points and Manchester City by 17 points are the most noticeable, but there have also been improvements by the likes of Aston Villa – the quality just outside the ‘big four’ has increased considerably. Despite Liverpool dropping out of the ‘top four’ this season, they still managed to reach the semi finals in the Europa League and 12th placed Fulham managed to beat the likes of Juventus and Hamburg en route to the final, again showing the quality outside of the top few places. The league has been won slightly less convincingly this season, and the competiton from United and Arsenal has been better in previous seasons, BUT it’s the rest of the league that have improved which still makes the PL arguably the best league in Europe.
For many years now Chelsea have been more than a one or two man team, sure we have our spine that still exists in some form or another but we highlight the importance of a good all round squad each and every season and don’t rely on single individuals – just look at our success without Drogba and Terry at times. Saying this though, at times you feel certain individuals have been so excellent within the team, they deserve individual praise and that’s what certain players have lacked from awards this time round.
The one thing the Premiership categorically NOT argue is the quality throughout the league. Tottenham made a leap forward, yes, and Manchester City did, as you would expect. Villa barely improved, Liverpool and Everton were considerably worse, and the quality in the bottom half was truly pathetic when compared to say, Serie A.
The whole ’struggling against top half’ thing is completely overstated – considering the quite obvious inequality between the top 8 and ‘the rest’, it’s inevitable that players will score more against the bottom half sides. But Rooney was excellent at Stamford Bridge and excellent at the Emirates. I seem to remember Drogba boosting his goal tally against Portsmouth. And Wigan. And Stoke. And Wolves. And West Ham. But I don’t think this really matters as goals can be vital even against bottom-half clubs, and both Rooney and Drogba were actually both very good in the ‘big’ games.
The goals/assists stats are interesting but don’t tell the whole story…United were quite poor in attacking areas this season, so it’s not surprise that Rooney is down on that front. And let’s not forget that Drogba was dropped for the “title decider” between the two clubs at Old Trafford, and was quite awful in two legs against Inter before disgracing himself as Chelsea got knocked out for the third consecutive season. It’s close between them certainly, but I don’t think Drogba is ‘clearly’ ahead at all.
Is it really overstated in the league only:
Rooney’s goals against the top eight – 5
Rooney’s goals against the bottom twelve – 21
Drogba’s goals against the top eight – 10
Drogba’s goals against the bottom twelve – 19
Always important to look at where the goals have come from, and while goals against ‘bottom twelve’ sides can be equally important it’s always interesting to see their record against the better sides in the league considering you see it as a huge gulf in class.
Wayne Rooney has had a fantastic season but being United’s lone striker, with much of the final attacking play going through him, it’s surprising to see him finish with less goals than Didier Drogba. Our attacks vary far more, and finish between a variety of players.
I meant rather that the concept of ‘goals versus the top half’ and ‘goals versus the bottom half’ are overstated, it’s a fairly irrelevant statistic and is sadly increasingly being used to support the old ‘big game bottler’ arguments.
Of course it’s not a surprise to see him finish less goals than Drogba – Chelsea were the better side overall, had better players supporting Drogba and were more attacking throughout the season…not to mention the fact that Drogba is more of a ‘finisher’ than Rooney anyway, whilst Rooney spent the run-in plainly unfit.
I’m sure if you asked people at the start of the season whether you expected Drogba or Rooney to score goals, the vast majority would have said Drogba.
Why’s that though? Rooney has scored more goals than him in the two seasons prior to this one, and with his role being switched to an out and out centre forward, everyone should have expected Rooney to once again score more than Didier Drogba – but this didn’t happen this season because Drogba stepped his game up and deserves credit. Rooney was unfit during the run in, but Drogba was away throughout January participating in a football tournament with a bunch of congested fixtures, but has still been able to carry on his excellent form right up until the last day of the season where he scored three goals against Wigan, before scoring the winner in the FA Cup final ensuring Chelsea’s first ever traditional domestic double.
We have been the more attacking side, which does in theory mean more chances for Didier Drogba (Rooney’s goal/shot ratio is only 1% better though) but whats also been so amazing about his season is the amount of assists he’s made (Again, Rooney had more assists in both seasons prior to this one), but this year according to the PL offical website Drogba finished with 13 compared to Rooney’s inferior tally of 5. Drogba finishes with 42 goals and assists combined in comparison to Rooney’s 30. Now, I’m not suggesting only statistics alone should decide an XI and we all know Drogba has a bad game once in a while, but most pointers suggest Drogba has had a better season than Wayne Rooney.
Only one quibble: “Messi’s record is probably even more incredible. He is still only 22.”
Ronaldo was 20.
And better than Messi.
Great site though.
Who would coach this side: The best Coach of 2009-10 – Jose Mourinho if not the all time best coach
:)
interesting team. the main objection is that clearly frank lampard should be in the team -
32 goals for the season, as well as providing the most assists in the premier league. he is a statistical freak! while he might not be the most skilful or pacy player, he is consistently the most effective club player in the world in terms of goals scored, assists, passes completed, chances created, games played etc.
i have to say, based on previous articles here about chelsea, i didn’t expect any of their players to be named in the team. this website is great in many ways, but it would be better still if the editor could look impartially at manchester united
Quite how do you think it is not impartial towards Manchester United?
the tone of a couple of articles have seemed like they were written by someone with a man utd perspective.
what’s great about this website is that in general, it sticks to tactical analysis and doesn’t get into ‘the ref cheated my team’..but there have been at least two articles implying that united were robbed by refereeing decisions against chelsea. (i think referring to a 50/50 free-kick given 35 yards from goal in november, which is the kind of detail only unhappy fans tend to remember)
also, there is the strange choice of wayne rooney for european goal of the season (undoubtedly a good goal, but mainly due to bad defending from arsenal)
the selection of wayne rooney ahead of didier drogba in the team of the year. i think the arguments have been spelt out above
-drogba scored more goals, despite playing less games and only taking one penalty
- drogba got 10 more assists, so is a better creator as well as goal-scorer
- drogba scored more of his goals in big games
- drogba is also chelsea’s best defender of set-pieces!
to give various awards to man utd players and nothing to chelsea players when chelsea have done the double, certainly suggests that there are different standards being applied…
but anyway, apart from this one blind spot, your website is one of the best football resources on the internet, so don’t worry too much!
As usual, unfounded claims of bias
Will add Manchester United to the list, though.
unfounded? hmm, the entire post was based on specifically providing three clear examples. if they were flawed in anyway then you’re free to explain why…
Flawed because I’m not a Manchester United supporter or biased towards them in any way.
Agree totally with Kev and Cam. But I don’t think ZM is a United fan. Chelsea generally don’t get the credit they deserve.
As a Barca-fan I think next year, David Villa, Iniesta will be up there. About the fullbacks, I think Abidal is really underestimated.
@zonalmarking.net
thanks for posting my vid (Robben)